Iowa’s Hy-Vee Now Ranks Below Save A Lot in a 2026 Grocery Satisfaction Index
You’ve shopped at Hy-Vee for years, and you figure it’s the best grocery store around.
A new nationwide survey of shoppers tells a different story.
Here’s how Iowa’s Hy-Vee now ranks below Save A Lot, and which chains scored higher.
Who Ran the Survey and How
Hy-Vee’s new spot comes from the American Customer Satisfaction Index (ACSI), a yearly customer survey that began in 1994 at the University of Michigan’s business school.
The ACSI calls itself a national economic indicator.
Each year, it asks customers to rate the companies they buy from.
The 2026 results come from randomly chosen customers who were emailed between January 2025 and December 2025.
The full retail study, which covers far more than supermarkets, is based on 31,293 completed surveys.
Its supermarket table covers 19 companies.
Customers rate their experience, and the ACSI turns the answers into a score from 0 to 100.
Higher means happier.
The results came out on Jan. 27, 2026, and they reflect a full calendar year of customer answers collected in 2025.
Here’s how the supermarket scores stacked up, starting with Hy-Vee’s drop, then the chains that scored higher.
The Five-Point Swing
Hy-Vee scored a 76 in the ACSI’s 2026 supermarket study, down from 78 the year before.
That 76 is a national score, not an Iowa-only rating.
Save A Lot moved the other way, rising from 75 to 78.
A year earlier, Hy-Vee led Save A Lot by three points, and now it trails by two, a five-point swing.
Shoppers rated Hy-Vee two points lower than they rated the average supermarket, which scored 78.
Many chains slipped, and the average fell a point, but we’d call a drop this size a rough year for Hy-Vee.
What Goes Into a Satisfaction Score
Hy-Vee’s 76 satisfaction score is, as the ACSI describes it, a weighted average of three survey questions.
A Department of Veterans Affairs report applying the method lists them as overall satisfaction, expectations met or missed, and comparison to an ideal.
All three come from customer answers, so the score tracks how shoppers feel, not a price comparison.
Chains Scoring Higher
Hy-Vee finished below 15 of the 19 chains in the ACSI’s supermarket table.
The top score in the table was 86, ten points above Hy-Vee.
Publix scored 84, eight points above Hy-Vee, and H-E-B’s 83 is seven points above.
Five points separate Hy-Vee from Aldi and Costco, which both scored 81.
Kroger and Meijer landed at 78, two points above.
A year earlier, Hy-Vee’s 78 matched Kroger’s, so that gap is new too.
Two chains went from behind Hy-Vee to ahead of it in a year: Save A Lot at 78 and BJ’s Wholesale Club at 77.
Six other chains also scored above Hy-Vee, between 78 and 82.
If you split your trips between Hy-Vee and Aldi or Costco, you’re comparing a 76 with an 81.
Three chains trail it: Walmart at 75, Albertsons Companies at 74 and Giant Eagle at 73.
Psst! How much do you know about grocery history? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.
Quiz
Grocery Aisle Trivia
Answer these questions on supermarket history. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?
In 1974, a supermarket in which state rang up the first product ever scanned with a barcode?
Supermarkets as a Group
Hy-Vee's drop came in a year when supermarkets as a group slipped 1%, to an ACSI score of 78.
Seven of the 19 chains didn't change at all, and seven more moved by a single point, six of them downward.
Only three chains dropped by more than a point: one fell 6%, and Hy-Vee and Albertsons Companies each fell 3%.
On whether the drop is an industry trend, Hy-Vee fell three times as far as the average.
That average is weighted by market share, so bigger chains count for more.
Across retail overall, the ACSI says satisfaction continues to inch forward, while supermarkets went the other way.
It adds that retailers face cost-conscious shoppers who aren't necessarily spending less but are spending differently, and that Aldi tops the Midwest.
The Biggest Gain
Hy-Vee's 3% drop stands out next to Save A Lot's gain, which at 4% was the largest among the 19 supermarket chains.
Only three chains improved, and Save A Lot led them.
The ACSI links the gain to 2025 changes, including an expanded loyalty program and mobile app, and says they seem to be contributing to a more efficient, streamlined in-store experience.
Store refreshes, reopening initiatives and layout improvements were part of the 2025 work too.
Save A Lot's 78 now ties Kroger, Meijer and Ahold Delhaize, three chains it trailed by three to four points a year earlier.
This table won't settle which chain costs less at your checkout.
The scores measure customer satisfaction, not a price comparison.
An Employee-Owned Chain
Hy-Vee is headquartered in West Des Moines, Iowa.
The company says it runs more than 550 retail locations across nine Midwestern states.
If you shop at one of those stores, you're buying from a company that says it has more than 75,000 employees.
Hy-Vee calls itself employee-owned.
Direct stockholders are officers, district store directors and executive staff.
Workers in the company's 401(k) plan hold stock indirectly, and more than 45,000 Hy-Vee employees take part in that plan.
Hy-Vee traces its start to 1930, when Charles Hyde and David Vredenburg opened a small general store in Beaconsfield, Iowa.
3 Casey's Pizza Facts That Trace Back to Iowa

Pick up dinner at a gas station, and out-of-staters may raise an eyebrow.
Casey's pizza has a hometown story, and it starts in Iowa.
3 Casey's Pizza Facts That Trace Back to Iowa
7 Iowa Landscapes That Look Nothing Like the Flat Cornfield Picture

Iowa has a reputation for flat fields as far as you can see.
These are some of the places that show a different side.
7 Iowa Landscapes That Look Nothing Like the Flat Cornfield Picture
