11 Things Georgians Learned in School About Georgia History That Turned Out to Be Wrong
You sat in a Georgia classroom and memorized how Atlanta got its name.
But the version in your old textbook isn’t the one historians tell now.
Here’s what Georgians learned in school about Georgia history that turned out to be wrong.
1. Debtors’ Colony
Many people learned the debtors’ colony version of the founding, where London’s jailed debtors got a fresh start.
James Oglethorpe’s early plan did include helping released debtors start over in America.
The plan then moved to sending the deserving poor.
By the time colonists were chosen, the New Georgia Encyclopedia says, not one formerly jailed debtor was among the first colonists selected.
The trustees looked for carpenters, tailors, bakers, farmers, and merchants.
That’s a hiring list.
So if you’ve told a friend that the colony began as a debtors’ prison, you can retire the line.
2. Slavery Ban
Some students learned that the colony’s early slavery ban was a moral stand by its founders.
It wasn’t.
Oglethorpe and the other trustees weren’t opposed to enslaving Africans as a matter of principle.
They banned slavery because it clashed with their social and economic intentions.
With Spanish Florida next door, slavery also seemed certain to threaten the colony’s military security.
Money and safety drove it.
The trustees proposed the ban in 1735.
Slavery became legal in Georgia in 1751.
If you learned the ban as a stand on principle, you can adjust that story.
3. Whitney and the Cotton Gin
Many people learned that Eli Whitney invented the first cotton gin.
Whitney built his gin in Georgia, where he lived for a year on Catharine Greene’s Mulberry Grove plantation near Savannah.
Gins for long-staple cotton existed long before his short-staple version.
He didn’t start from zero.
Joseph Eve of Augusta patented an improved gin that used roller ginning in 1788.
The evidence still indicates Whitney did invent the saw gin, which he patented while in Georgia in 1793.
His working gin could produce up to fifty pounds of cotton a day.
If you learned he invented the first cotton gin, you can now narrow the claim to the saw gin.
4. Jackson’s Famous Line
Many people learned Andrew Jackson’s famous reply to the Supreme Court’s Cherokee ruling.
The 1832 ruling in Worcester v. Georgia struck down Georgia’s extension laws.
Jackson is widely quoted as daring Chief Justice John Marshall to enforce the decision himself, the New Georgia Encyclopedia notes.
His actual words, in a letter to General John Coffee, were different.
He wrote that the ruling had fallen stillborn and couldn’t force Georgia to comply.
Georgia ignored the Supreme Court’s ruling and refused to release the missionaries.
Jackson didn’t enforce it.
Instead, he called on the Cherokees to relocate or fall under Georgia’s jurisdiction.
If you remember the dare, you can swap in the letter to Coffee.
5. Cherokee Treaty
Many people learned that the Cherokee agreed to leave through the Treaty of New Echota.
A faction led by Major Ridge signed the treaty in 1835 at the Cherokee capital.
They signed without the authority of Principal Chief Ross or the Cherokee government.
Ross pushed back.
He gathered 16,000 Cherokee signatures against the treaty.
The U.S. Senate still ratified it by a margin of one vote.
Soldiers later rounded up as many Cherokees as they could into temporary stockades.
If you learned it as an agreement, the signatures should change your mind.
6. Secession Vote
Some people learned that the secession vote spoke with one voice.
The numbers say otherwise.
In the statewide vote before the convention, immediate secessionists won, at best, a tiny majority of the ballots cast, 44,152 to 41,632.
Delegates adopted the secession ordinance on January 19, 1861, by a vote of 208 to 89.
Immediate secessionists still had a controlling majority at the convention.
The state was divided.
If you remember it as unanimous, those numbers should surprise you.
Psst! How much do you know about Georgia’s founding years? Take our quiz and see how many you can get right.
Quiz
Founding Years Trivia
Answer these questions on Georgia’s colonial and Revolutionary years. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?
How many delegates did Georgia send to the First Continental Congress in Philadelphia in 1774?
7. States' Rights Story
Some people learned that secession came down to states' rights.
Georgia's declaration of causes, approved on January 29, 1861, tells a different story.
It says the question of slavery was the great difficulty in forming the Constitution.
It also describes the North's fixed purpose as limiting, restraining, and finally abolishing slavery in the states where it exists.
Slavery is the subject.
The New Georgia Encyclopedia ties secession to nearly two decades of sectional conflict over slavery in the western territories.
If you were told it was about states' rights, you can check the document yourself.
8. Sherman's Scorched-Earth Reputation
Many people learned that Sherman's army burned everything between Atlanta and the sea.
Sherman didn't level any towns, the New Georgia Encyclopedia says, but he did destroy buildings in places where there was resistance.
His men destroyed the food and forage in their path.
The army moved in two wings, usually twenty to forty miles apart.
That's not the same as leveling towns.
Atlanta is the harder case.
Fires on November 15, 1864 consumed many homes and businesses that weren't marked for destruction.
If your lesson pictured one long bonfire, ask what the army targeted before you picture the whole state in flames.
9. Savannah Exception
Many people learned that Sherman spared Savannah because he admired its beauty.
Hardee withdrew and Mayor Arnold surrendered.
Confederate General Hardee pulled his men out toward South Carolina so Savannah wouldn't be shelled the way Atlanta was.
Sherman was away when Mayor Richard Arnold surrendered Savannah.
He wasn't even there.
Sherman then wired President Lincoln on December 22, 1864, and offered him the city as a Christmas present.
If you've repeated the beauty story, you can swap in the surrender.
10. Forty Acres and a Mule
Many people learned the phrase "forty acres and a mule" as a single promise.
Sherman's Field Order No. 15 is the likely origin of the phrase, the New Georgia Encyclopedia says.
Mules came in a later order, when Sherman authorized the army to loan them to the newly settled farmers.
Those mules were loans.
Field Order No. 15 followed a January 12 meeting where Sherman and Secretary of War Stanton met with twenty Black leaders of the Savannah community.
Many were Baptist and Methodist ministers.
The phrase spread throughout the South in the weeks and months after Sherman's march.
If you've used the phrase before, you can now say where the mule fits in.
What Field Order No. 15 Covered
Sherman's Field Order No. 15 set aside roughly 400,000 acres for newly freed Black families, in forty-acre segments.
President Andrew Johnson overturned the order in the fall of 1865.
He returned much of the land along the South Carolina, Georgia, and Florida coasts to the planters who had originally owned it.
11. Atlanta's Name Origin
Many people learned that Atlanta took its name from a girl's middle name.
The railroad town around the zero milepost started out as Terminus, which means end of the line.
In 1843, the town became Marthasville, named for the daughter of former governor Wilson Lumpkin.
Atlanta came two years later.
John Edgar Thomson, chief engineer of the Georgia Railroad, first used the name for his railroad's local depot.
If you tell the story, you can say the name is supposedly a feminine version of the word Atlantic.
Lumpkin reportedly insisted the name also honored his daughter, whose middle name was Atalanta.
That account appears to be apocryphal.
Peachtree Name
Many people learned that Peachtree Street got its name from peach trees.
The Georgia Historical Society's marker for Standing Peach Tree says the name may trace to a peach tree or to what the marker calls a pitch tree.
Standing Peach Tree was a Creek village at the mouth of Peachtree Creek.
One early use the marker cites is a governor's 1782 letter.
The origin stays uncertain.
If you've told an out-of-stater the street honors peach trees, you can add that the marker leaves it open.
8 Things Only a Georgia Childhood Teaches You

Not everything you learned as a kid came from a textbook.
Some of what Georgians took for granted looks different in other states.
8 Things Only a Georgia Childhood Teaches You
5 Things That Were Normal in the 1950s That Georgia and Federal Law Now Restrict

Ask older relatives about life in the 1950s, and you'll hear things that sound unthinkable now.
Some of those things are now restricted.
5 Things That Were Normal in the 1950s That Georgia and Federal Law Now Restrict
