6 Buckeye Candy Opinions That Start Arguments in Ohio Kitchens

Your buckeyes are dipped, and now you’re standing in front of the fridge and the freezer wondering which one is right.

Ask three Ohioans, and you’ll get three answers.

Here are the buckeye candy opinions that start arguments in Ohio kitchens.

1. Rice Krispies in the Filling

Buckeye candy gets a crunch in some northwestern Ohio kitchens, where makers stir Rice Krispies into the peanut butter mixture, the Columbus Dispatch reports.

Gail Tabor’s original recipe lists no Rice Krispies among its sugar, butter, peanut butter, vanilla, chocolate chips and wax.

Renee Casteel Cook, who wrote Ohio Buckeye Candy: A Sweet History, says the add-in is polarizing.

If you grew up on a smooth filling, a crunchy batch can taste like a different candy.

2. Toothpick Holes

A buckeye pulled off its toothpick leaves a hole in the peanut butter circle.

Makers don’t agree on what to do about it.

Jane Cook, Renee Casteel Cook’s mother-in-law and what the Dispatch calls a prolific buckeye producer, insists on closing it.

Jane Cook’s recipe says to smooth over the hole and let the chocolate set.

Some commercial producers insist on leaving it visible, the Dispatch says, as a sign their buckeyes are made by hand.

Saveur’s buckeye recipe includes a step to smooth out the toothpick holes left in the peanut butter.

Leave the hole, and you’re with those producers; close it, and you’re with Jane Cook.

3. Wax in the Chocolate

Candy wax gets a caution from a Post Bulletin cooking column, which says paraffin isn’t approved as a safe food additive.

The column adds that paraffin was common in old candy recipes and that most sources suggest skipping it, though it calls the small amount used not a major problem.

Gail Tabor’s original buckeye candy recipe melts one block of canning wax in with 12 ounces of chocolate chips.

Jane Cook’s version calls for a third of a block of paraffin wax.

Saveur’s recipe melts vegetable shortening with the chocolate chips and lists no wax.

That recipe pairs 6 ounces of semisweet chocolate chips with half a teaspoon of the shortening.

If you’re working from a recipe card handed down in your family, check which of these it calls for before you melt anything.

Psst! How much do you know about the Buckeye State? Take our quiz and see how many you can get right.

Quiz

Buckeye State IQ

Answer these questions on Ohio State, Ohio’s state symbols and the buckeye tree. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 10

In the 1934 Michigan game tied to Ohio State’s Gold Pants Club, what was the score?

4. Peanut Butter Ratio

Buckeye recipes start with powdered sugar, butter and peanut butter, but they disagree on how much of each.

Experience Columbus prints Gail Tabor's original recipe with 4 pounds of powdered sugar, 1 pound of butter and 6 or more tablespoons of peanut butter.

Saveur's recipe uses 2 cups of confectioners' sugar, three-quarters of a cup of peanut butter and 4 tablespoons of butter.

Saveur also adds a quarter teaspoon of salt, and Tabor's ingredient list has none.

Renee Casteel Cook's mother-in-law, Jane Cook, thinks the original recipe has too much sugar.

5. Freezer or Fridge

Experience Columbus prints Gail Tabor's original recipe with a last step to store the finished buckeyes in plastic bags in the freezer.

Saveur's recipe also uses the freezer, but only to firm the buckeyes: 15 to 20 minutes for the rolled balls and until firm for the dipped ones.

For storage, Saveur points to a cool place or the refrigerator instead.

If you're making a batch ahead of a party, you pick the waiting spot, whether that's the freezer, the refrigerator or a cool place.

How Long Buckeye Candy Keeps

Saveur's buckeye recipe says sealed buckeyes keep well in a cool place for up to one week.

In the refrigerator, it says, they keep well for up to two weeks.

It says to serve them at room temperature or chilled.

6. Credit for the Recipe

Experience Columbus says Gail Tabor, a former Columbus Citizen Journal reporter, is widely credited with creating buckeye candy in 1964.

A 2024 Fox News story is less sure, saying there's no true proof that the alleged creator reimagined the recipe herself.

Tabor wrote that she gave her recipe to one acquaintance before she moved away in 1971.

In Tabor's account, the acquaintance asked to take it away and maintain the secrecy, and Tabor said she obliged.

Fox News says the acquaintance later claimed the recipe as hers in an Ohio State alumni magazine submission.

How the Buckeye Got Its Look

Part of what makes buckeye candy look like a buckeye is the small portion left uncovered.

In December 1964, Tabor was covering peanut butter balls with chocolate, Fox News says.

When Tabor dipped her first ball, she didn't get it completely covered.

Tabor later wrote that she held it up on the toothpick and saw a buckeye.

Her original recipe, as Experience Columbus prints it, tells you to leave a small portion uncovered.

Saveur's recipe puts a number on it, with a dip of about three-quarters of the ball.

That leaves a circle of peanut butter showing at the top.

If you dip deeper, less peanut butter shows on your tray.

The Shop Versions

Experience Columbus has listed 12 bakeries, candy makers and other shops as stops on its Buckeye Treat Trail.

Krema Nut Company and Anthony-Thomas Candy Company are both on the list.

If you'd rather buy than roll, you can use that list of shops as a place to start.

Buckeyes by the Thousands at St. Andrews

At St. Andrews Catholic Church in Upper Arlington, Jane Cook and others would make 5,000 buckeyes for sales, the Dispatch says.

Saveur's recipe makes about 30 buckeyes.

At that yield, 5,000 buckeyes would take about 167 batches of the recipe.

12 Words Ohioans Used in the 1960s That Make No Sense Today

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Some words can date you faster than a birth certificate.

Many older Ohioans used these words every day, and now they mostly draw confused looks.

12 Words Ohioans Used in the 1960s That Make No Sense Today

13 Things Ohioans Do at a Tailgate That Confuse Everyone From Out of State

Image Credit: aceshot1 / Shutterstock.com.

Tailgating takes a parking lot, a game and something on the grill.

Ohioans often take it further, and fans from other states don't always know what to make of it.

13 Things Ohioans Do at a Tailgate That Confuse Everyone From Out of State

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *