5 Phone Habits That Can Now Cost Pennsylvanians a Fine Under the Hands-Free Law

If your phone slides off the seat on the drive to Thanksgiving dinner, you’d probably reach for it without thinking.

That quick grab isn’t as harmless in Pennsylvania as it used to be.

Here are the habits that cost Pennsylvanians a fine now that the hands-free law’s warning period is over.

Note: This is general information, not legal advice. Driving laws and fines are subject to change, so confirm the current rules with the Pennsylvania Department of Transportation (PennDOT).

1. Scrolling at a Red Light

Pennsylvania’s hands-free law is known as Paul Miller’s Law.

It treats a red light as part of driving, so holding your phone there breaks the law.

So does a traffic jam.

Pennsylvania’s older texting ban covers only a car that’s in motion.

Paul Miller’s Law makes no such exception.

Even a quick scroll counts as use.

The fine is $50, plus court costs and other fees.

It’s also a primary offense, so an officer can stop you for the phone alone.

So at your next red light, keep the phone out of your hand.

2. Pinning the Phone to Your Shoulder

The hands-free law bans holding a phone or supporting it with another part of your body.

Cradling one between your ear and your shoulder falls into the second group.

A shoulder isn’t a mount.

Holding it up to your ear for a call is use as well.

Calls through hands-free technology stay legal, though.

Convicted drivers pay $50 plus court costs and other fees.

3. Tapping More Than Once to Place a Call

The hands-free law treats more than a single button press to place or answer a call as using your phone.

The older texting ban makes an exception for entering a phone number or name to place a call.

One press is the limit.

If you’re convicted, that second press costs $50 plus court costs.

Psst! How much do you know about Pennsylvania’s roads? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.

Quiz

Pennsylvania Road IQ

Answer nine questions on Pennsylvania’s roads, rules, and Turnpike. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 9

When your windshield wipers are running because of the weather, Pennsylvania’s driver’s manual says you also need to have what turned on?

4. Reaching for a Fallen Phone

Even reaching for your phone can count as using it under the hands-free law, when the reach pulls you out of a seated driving position, restrained by a seat belt.

Position is the test.

You may pick it up once you've stopped somewhere safe.

Outside that exception, the same $50 fine plus fees applies.

5. Snapping Photos or Video

If you take photos with a hand-held phone, that counts as using it under Paul Miller's Law.

The same list includes texting, calling, emailing, and scrolling through social media.

So does video.

Posting to social media is covered too, when you do it with the phone in your hand.

Photos fall under the same $50 fine, with court costs and other fees on top.

What Stays Legal Under Paul Miller's Law

Paul Miller's Law still lets you use your phone hands-free for calls, navigation directions, and music.

A phone in a mount counts as hands-free, as long as you don't hold it.

Calling 911 or another emergency service is exempt, too.

The Warning Year by the Numbers

Paul Miller's Law came with a 12-month warning period, which ran from June 5, 2025, until it ended in June 2026.

The Pennsylvania State Police issued 1,616 warnings during that year.

Then the tickets started.

From June 8 to 10, troopers ran a statewide enforcement effort called Operation Hands Off.

It produced 694 citations and 308 warnings related to Paul Miller's Law.

That works out to roughly 230 citations a day across those three days.

Those counts leave out local police departments.

The Texting Ban Still Applies

The hands-free law didn't replace Pennsylvania's texting ban.

Sending, reading, or writing a text while your car is moving is still a separate offense, with a $50 fine.

A texting violation carries no points and isn't recorded on a non-commercial driver's record.

What about overlap?

You can't be charged under both laws for the same time and place.

The Crashes Behind the Law

The hands-free law is named for Paul Miller Jr., a 21-year-old college senior killed by a distracted driver in 2010.

That driver became distracted while reaching for a phone.

The law followed more than a decade of advocacy by his parents, Eileen and Paul Miller.

How common are those crashes?

PennDOT reported 9,950 crashes involving a distracted driver in 2024.

Those crashes left more than 6,000 people injured and 49 dead.

A driver convicted of homicide by vehicle while distracted can also face up to 5 additional years in prison.

Data on Hand-Held Stops

Paul Miller's Law also requires police to collect data on hand-held phone stops.

Who sees that data?

State police or a designated third party will compile a report on that data every year.

Because it's exempt from the state's Right-to-Know law, the data itself stays out of public view.

7 Pennsylvania Foods and Drinks With Origins Pennsylvanians Get Completely Wrong

Image Credit: John Arehart / Shutterstock.com.

A Philadelphia soup supposedly kept George Washington's starving army alive through the Valley Forge winter of 1777-78.

Historians have something to say about that.

7 Pennsylvania Foods and Drinks With Origins Pennsylvanians Get Completely Wrong

8 Things Pennsylvanians Can't Legally Leave at the Curb

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Setting the wrong item out on trash day can break your township's waste code before you ever notice.

You could even owe a fine.

8 Things Pennsylvanians Can't Legally Leave at the Curb

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *