7 Big Differences Between Hy-Vee and Fareway Every Iowan Should Know

Picking between Hy-Vee and Fareway feels like choosing a side at the family reunion.

Both have loyal fans.

Your cart looks about the same leaving either store, but the stores behind those carts aren’t.

Here are the big differences between Hy-Vee and Fareway that many Iowans should know.

1. Different Hometowns

Hy-Vee and Fareway both come out of Iowa, but if you trace each one back, you land in different towns.

Hy-Vee began in 1930, when Charles Hyde and David Vredenburg opened a small store in Beaconsfield.

The store was leased only a few weeks before the stock market crash of October 1929.

Hy-Vee had the head start.

Fareway’s first store opened eight years later, on May 12, 1938, at 624 Story Street in Boone.

The opening was a dream realized for founder Paul S. Beckwith, who had spent years as a meat supervisor for one of the country’s largest grocery chains.

If you’re picking a favorite by hometown, it’s Beaconsfield versus Boone.

Fareway’s corporate headquarters operated in Boone, while Hy-Vee’s corporate offices moved to West Des Moines in 1995.

2. Name Origins

The names Hy-Vee and Fareway come from two different places.

If you’ve ever wondered what Hy-Vee means, it’s a contraction of its founders’ names, Hyde and Vredenburg.

A 1952 contest picked the winning name.

Until then, each store went by its town’s name plus Supply Store or Service Store.

Fareway took a different route.

Fareway’s name was chosen to convey three meanings, and one of them has nothing to do with food.

The first is a wide range of “fare,” or foods.

The second is a “bill of fare,” a commonly used phrase for a grocery list.

The third is treating customers and employees fairly.

Say Fareway out loud, and you can hear the fair way tucked inside.

3. Store Ownership

Hy-Vee says it’s employee-owned, and Fareway says it’s family-owned.

That’s two different answers.

Fareway describes itself as a family-owned business.

Its chairman of the board is Paul Beckwith’s granddaughter, Dr. P. Sue Beckwith.

If you care who’s behind the name on your receipt, you’ve got employees on one side and a family on the other.

Hy-Vee set up its Employees’ Trust Fund in 1960, so all eligible employees could share in the ownership of the company.

Hy-Vee also calls every employee a stakeholder in the company’s future.

How Hy-Vee’s Employee Ownership Works

Unlike family-owned Fareway, Hy-Vee’s employee ownership comes in two layers.

Direct stockholders are officers, district store directors and executive staff members.

Indirect stockholders are the more than 45,000 Hy-Vee employees who take part through the company’s 401(k) plan.

Iowa’s Homestead Exemption for 65 and Older: 4 Rules Homeowners Miss When Filing

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Many older Iowa homeowners skim past a safety certification on the homestead application.

It’s not the only item that’s easy to miss.

Iowa’s Homestead Exemption for 65 and Older: 4 Rules Homeowners Miss When Filing

4. Store Counts

Hy-Vee and Fareway don’t count their stores the same way.

Hy-Vee operates more than 540 business units across nine Midwestern states.

Fareway has roughly 140 stores across seven states: Iowa, Illinois, Kansas, Minnesota, Nebraska, Missouri and South Dakota.

Hy-Vee covers two more states.

Hy-Vee’s figure is in business units, so you shouldn’t read the two numbers like a scoreboard.

Psst! How much do you know about Iowa’s food and farms? Take our quiz and see how many you can get right.

Quiz

Iowa Food IQ

Answer these questions on Iowa food, farm and grocery trivia. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 9

About how much butter goes into the Iowa State Fair’s butter cow?

5. Crossing State Lines

Hy-Vee was a two-state business before Fareway had a single store.

On January 1, 1938, Hyde and Vredenburg and 14 others incorporated 15 stores in Iowa and Missouri.

Fareway's first store opened in Boone that May.

Stores soon followed in Ames, Webster City, Fort Dodge, Estherville, Carroll and Oelwein.

Every one of those towns is in Iowa.

Fareway stayed close to home.

Minnesota became Hy-Vee's third state in 1969, when it merged with Swanson's Stores Inc.

South Dakota followed in 1975, Nebraska in 1977 and Illinois in 1979.

Kansas became its seventh state in 1988, and Wisconsin its eighth in 2009.

Fareway's history page lists its seven states, but it doesn't say when the chain first left Iowa.

You can see the difference in how each chain built its map.

6. Workforce Size

Hy-Vee and Fareway employ very different numbers of people.

Hy-Vee has more than 75,000 employees.

Fareway has over 12,000, spread across its seven-state region.

If you line the two payrolls up, you'll see they sit on different scales.

That's a wide gap.

Fareway also calls itself a top 10 employer in Iowa.

7. Online Ordering

Hy-Vee and Fareway came to online grocery shopping on different schedules.

Hy-Vee introduced customers to online grocery shopping in 1998, and Hy-Vee Aisles Online was fully implemented in October 2015.

Hy-Vee's Aisles Online page also notes that prices, promotions and availability may vary by store, so you'll want to check your store before you build a cart.

Hy-Vee says Aisles Online lets you shop through its website with pickup or delivery options.

Fareway's curbside pickup started at its Boone store in January 2021, and the company announced the full rollout that August.

Curbside came to Boone first.

Fareway's online shopping FAQ lists a $30 minimum order and no fee.

The FAQ describes pickup only, with no mention of delivery.

The same FAQ says online shopping is available at select stores, so you'll want to find yours in the pickup list before you order.

When you finalize your order, you pick from the available pickup times, park in a reserved spot, and staff bring your order out and load it in your vehicle.

7 Fall-Prevention Fixes Older Iowans Can Make Before the First Ice

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

If you use a cane, an ice tip can make it a lot steadier on winter sidewalks.

Many older Iowans still have time to make fixes like that.

7 Fall-Prevention Fixes Older Iowans Can Make Before the First Ice

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *