6 Things Iowans Don’t Realize About Shopping at an Employee-Owned Hy-Vee

They say if you want something done right, do it yourself.

Hy-Vee took that a step further and let the people doing the work own a piece of the company.

How that works is more interesting than the label suggests.

Here are the things Iowans don’t realize about shopping at an employee-owned Hy-Vee.

1. Stakeholders and Stockholders

Hy-Vee’s employee-owned label covers more than one kind of stake.

Hy-Vee calls every employee a stakeholder in the company’s future.

If you’re like many shoppers, you hear employee-owned and assume the person bagging your groceries holds the same slice of the company as the person running it.

Hy-Vee describes its owners as direct stockholders, meaning officers, district store directors and executive staff members, and as indirect stockholders.

Supermarket News reported back in 2005 that the company’s structure has direct and indirect stockholders.

So the courtesy clerk helping you with your cart is a stakeholder, while a district store director is a direct stockholder.

2. Company Stock in the 401(k)

At Hy-Vee, employee ownership reaches the person ringing up your groceries through a retirement plan that can leave them holding company stock, Progressive Grocer reported.

Part of the company’s matching contribution to the Hy-Vee and Affiliates 401(k) Plan goes into the Hy-Vee Stock Fund.

That means a cashier’s retirement savings can include a stake in the company behind the store you’re standing in.

More than 45,000 employees take part in the plan, and Hy-Vee calls them indirect stockholders.

Hy-Vee calls the Stock Fund account technically the company’s largest shareholder, which makes the biggest name on the list an account instead of a person.

Back in 2005, Supermarket News counted about 22,000 employees among Hy-Vee’s owners.

They made up 47% of the chain’s staff then.

3. Fully Vested Match

Hy-Vee says all active employees are 100% vested in its 401(k) matching contributions, the same match that feeds the Stock Fund.

Many people picture a retirement match as something you earn after years on the job.

In a retirement plan, vesting means ownership, and the plan’s paperwork sets a schedule that can run from immediate to several years.

Progressive Grocer reported that Hy-Vee’s active employees became fully vested in 2020.

The company also raised its match that September to 50% of every dollar contributed, up to the first 7% of pay.

So when you chat with a cashier at your Hy-Vee, that employee isn’t waiting out a vesting schedule for any match, though Hy-Vee’s wording covers active employees.

Psst! How much do you know about Iowa food and farming? Take our quiz and see how many you can get right.

Quiz

Iowa Farm and Food IQ

Answer nine questions on Iowa farming and food history. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 9

About how much butter goes into the Iowa State Fair’s butter cow?

4. Store Managers as Owners

Before the company carried the Hy-Vee name, its store managers were sharing in the profits, and then the ownership.

In 1933, Supermarket News reported, the company began paying store managers a share of each store's net profits instead of wages.

The International Directory of Company Histories says the 1938 corporation was owned by store managers who traded ownership in their local stores for corporate stock.

In 2005, the company's leaders described Hy-Vee's store directors as running their stores like owners.

Back then, store employees were responsible for decisions on pricing, procurement and selling, the company's executives said.

The Hy-Vee name on your store's sign didn't arrive until a company contest in 1952 blended the founders' surnames.

5. Employees' Trust Fund

The Employees' Trust Fund Hy-Vee created in 1960 became the company's primary stockholder and made every participant an indirect stockholder.

That's why the person at your register holds company stock, if at all, through the plan instead of directly.

Until 1959, Supermarket News reported, employees could own Hy-Vee stock but had to sell it back to the company when they left.

Think of it as handing back your shares along with your name tag.

Then securities law changes required privately held companies like Hy-Vee to restrict direct stock sales or offer shares to the public.

Hy-Vee says the fund let all eligible employees share in the company's ownership, which the company calls the beginning of its tradition of being known as an employee-owned business.

6. Stock Without a Ticker

The National Center for Employee Ownership (NCEO) counts Hy-Vee among 17 companies on Forbes' 2024 list of the 100 largest private companies that have some form of employee ownership.

Forbes ranks that list by sales, so Hy-Vee's 35th spot measures revenue, not how many employees own a piece.

Privately held companies don't list their shares, so you can't buy Hy-Vee stock on an exchange the way you'd buy a publicly traded grocer's.

That count only includes companies with reliable outside verification that their plans are broad-based.

Broad-based means the plan reaches employees across the company instead of a handful of executives.

A Plan Funded by Profits

Hy-Vee funds the profit-sharing trust and 401(k) plan behind its employee ownership with a portion of its before-tax profits.

Hy-Vee says that plan gives its employees ownership in the company.

So some of the profit from your trip through the checkout lane can end up in the plan.

An earlier NCEO table described Hy-Vee's plan as a profit sharing plan primarily invested in company stock.

The Trust Behind the Stock

Supermarket News reported in 2005 that employee ownership usually runs through an employee stock ownership plan (ESOP), but that Hy-Vee uses a trust instead.

So if you've read about ESOPs at other employee-owned companies, Hy-Vee's setup works differently.

A second 2005 profile described Hy-Vee as remaining privately held, with no intention of going public or selling the company.

In 2005, the trust pegged the stock's value to book value, while an ESOP's value comes from an appraiser.

Book value comes from a company's books, so in 2005 the number followed what Hy-Vee had on paper instead of an outside expert's estimate of the business.

9 Precautions Iowans Should Take When Shopping at Hy-Vee

Image Credit: Kit Leong / Shutterstock.com.

A full cart makes a small mistake hurt more.

These are the Hy-Vee precautions Iowans should take before their next trip through the checkout lane.

9 Precautions Iowans Should Take When Shopping at Hy-Vee

9 Hy-Vee Secrets Employees Wish Iowans Knew

Image Credit: Juli Hansen / Shutterstock.com.

Hy-Vee employees see the store from the other side of the counter.

Their list of secrets is worth a read before your next trip.

9 Hy-Vee Secrets Employees Wish Iowans Knew

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *