17 New York Spots Boomers Loved That Closed for Good
New York has always torn down its past to build its future.
Sometimes that future is a luxury tower. Sometimes it’s a parking lot.
Either way, the places baby boomers grew up loving keep vanishing.
Here are the ones that left a mark when they went.
1. The Horn & Hardart Automat
Drop a nickel in the slot, turn the chrome knob, and a little glass door popped open with a slice of pie behind it.
No waiters. No judgment.
Just hot food and shining brass.
The Automat fed New York for decades, from the Depression through the postwar boom.
Television and fast food chipped away at it. The last one closed on 42nd Street in 1991, and a one-of-a-kind New York magic went with it.
2. Freedomland U.S.A.
Before Disney World, the Bronx had its own giant theme park, shaped like a map of the entire country.
Freedomland opened in 1960 with a Great Chicago Fire you could help put out and a stagecoach robbery every twenty minutes.
It lasted only through 1964.
Co-op City stands on the spot now, but the boomers who rode that steamboat as kids never forgot it.
3. Ebbets Field
Ask any Brooklyn boomer of a certain age, and the wound is still fresh.
The Dodgers left for Los Angeles after 1957, and the heart of the borough went with them.
The ballpark itself came down in 1960.
Apartment towers rose where Jackie Robinson once stole home.
Brooklyn got over a lot of things. It never got over this.
4. Gimbels
Does Macy’s tell Gimbels? For decades, the two giants went toe to toe block by block in Herald Square.
Gimbels ran the bargains, and a shopping floor your mother knew by heart.
The chain shut down in 1987.
A shopping mall fills its old Herald Square home now, and the rivalry lives on only in old movies like Miracle on 34th Street.
5. Grossinger’s
Up in the Catskills, Grossinger’s was the grandest resort in the Borscht Belt.
Comedians, golf, romance, and more food than any human could finish.
Eddie Fisher married Debbie Reynolds there. Rocky Marciano trained there. If you’ve seen Dirty Dancing, you’ve seen its fictional cousin.
Cheap flights to Florida and beyond emptied the mountains out.
Grossinger’s closed in 1986 and crumbled into the trees.
6. Mama Leone’s
Near Times Square, Mama Leone’s piled the antipasto high and hung plastic grapes from every rafter. Nobody pretended it was authentic.
After a Broadway show, that was the whole point.
The accordion played. The Chianti came in straw-wrapped bottles. Tour buses idled out front.
When Times Square cleaned up and rents soared, Mama Leone’s closed in 1994.
Broadway lost one of its loudest, warmest rooms.
7. Steeplechase Park
Coney Island had a grinning face you never forgot. The Funny Face logo of Steeplechase Park watched over the boardwalk for generations.
You rode the mechanical horses, got blown around by air jets, and laughed until your sides hurt.
It closed in 1964, the last of the great Coney Island parks to go.
The Parachute Jump still stands nearby, a rusting ghost of all that fun.
8. The Original Penn Station
Today’s Penn Station is a low-ceilinged maze. The first one was a wonder.
Soaring stone columns. Glass and steel arches. Light pouring down through a vast roof, making you feel small in the best way.
They started tearing it down in 1963 to build Madison Square Garden on top.
The loss hit so hard it sparked the city’s whole landmark-protection movement. Too late for Penn Station.
9. Shea Stadium
Out in Queens, Shea Stadium gave the Mets a home and gave boomers a front-row seat to history.
The Beatles played there in 1965, the first stadium rock concert anyone had seen, the screams so loud the band couldn’t hear themselves.
The Mets moved next door to Citi Field, and Shea came down in 2009.
The parking lot still holds the ghosts of a few miracle seasons.
10. B. Altman & Co.
On Fifth Avenue, B. Altman sold elegance to generations of New Yorkers.
White gloves, fine furniture, a tearoom where ladies lunched after a morning of shopping.
It opened in 1865 and ran on old-world manners until the very end.
Changing tastes and big debt caught up with it, and B. Altman closed in 1989.
The grand building survived. Students at the CUNY Graduate Center walk its old floors now.
11. Lundy’s
Down in Sheepshead Bay, Lundy’s served Brooklyn its Sunday seafood in a building the size of a small castle.
Shore dinners, biscuits, clam chowder, and a dining room that could seat what felt like the whole borough.
After a long decline and a brief comeback, Lundy’s closed for good in 2007.
Brooklyn lost the place where families marked every big occasion with a lobster.
12. Tower Records
Before playlists, you flipped through the racks at Tower Records until your fingers got dusty.
The downtown store stayed open late, the staff argued about B-sides, and you walked out with an album you’d play until it wore thin.
The whole chain went under in 2006.
A generation that bought music by holding it in their hands lost its clubhouse.
13. Lüchow’s
For over a century, Lüchow’s served German feasts on 14th Street near Union Square.
Sauerbraten, steins of beer, oompah bands, and Christmas celebrations that drew the whole city.
Generations of families had their big nights there.
The grand old room closed in 1982. Fire and demolition finished the building off not long after, and a New York landmark became a memory.
14. The Polo Grounds
Up in Harlem, the horseshoe-shaped Polo Grounds was home to the New York Giants and their famous bathtub of an outfield.
Willie Mays made The Catch here in the 1954 World Series, over his shoulder, back to the plate, one of the greatest plays anyone ever saw.
The Giants left for San Francisco after 1957.
The Mets borrowed the place for two seasons, then the wrecking ball arrived in 1964.
15. Roseland Ballroom
Roseland was where New York went to dance for nearly a century.
Big bands, then disco, then rock, under one famous roof off Broadway.
Sinatra sang there. Couples met there, fell in love there, and some of them married because of a night there.
Roseland closed in 2014 with one last run of shows.
A luxury tower took its place, and the music stopped for good.
16. Howard Johnson’s
The orange roof meant you’d arrived. Howard Johnson’s served fried clams and 28 flavors of ice cream to road-tripping families all over the Northeast.
The Times Square location hung on after the rest of the city’s HoJo’s faded, a holdout from a simpler era.
It shuttered in 2005.
The orange roofs disappeared from the map, and a piece of every boomer family vacation went with them.
17. Ratner’s
On the Lower East Side, Ratner’s served blintzes, matzo ball soup, and onion rolls to anyone who walked through the door.
The waiters were famously gruff, the kind who’d known your family for thirty years.
Even Meyer Lansky had a regular table.
By 2002, the neighborhood had changed, and the old kosher dairy crowd had thinned.
Ratner’s closed, and a chapter of immigrant New York closed with it.
10 New York Property Tax Breaks Seniors Forget to Claim Every Year
New York property taxes are famously brutal. What’s less famous is how much relief the state offers homeowners over 65, and how much of it goes unclaimed.
Here’s what New York seniors keep leaving on the table, and how to collect every dollar.
10 New York Property Tax Breaks Seniors Forget to Claim Every Year
15 Timeless 1950s Favorites Baby Boomers Can’t Forget
For many people, the 1950s conjure images of poodle skirts and soda fountains.
Whether you lived through this decade or you’ve only heard stories about it, here’s a trip down memory lane about this period of American culture.
15 Timeless 1950s Favorites American Baby Boomers Can’t Forget
