9 Mistakes Pennsylvanians Make When Buying Food at Sheetz
Buying food at Sheetz in Pennsylvania is the best, if you ask us. It’s fast, tasty, and honestly, just plain fun. You’ve got a whole screen of options in front of you, from hot dogs to mac and cheese bites to those giant MTO subs that hit the spot every time.
But even with all the love we’ve got for Sheetz, it’s still easy to make a few rookie mistakes while ordering.
If you want to get the most out of every visit (and every bite), here are some slip-ups to avoid.
Going Overboard with the Toppings
Sheetz gives you so many topping options, it feels like building your own masterpiece. But just because you can add five sauces, three cheeses, and every veggie under the sun doesn’t mean you should.
Ever tried eating a meatball sub with banana peppers, pickles, Boom Boom sauce, and ranch all at once?
It’s a mess. A delicious mess, sure—but also a total disaster.
When you’re piling on everything, your hoagie starts falling apart, and now you’re holding a soggy paper bag instead of lunch.
Our advice?
Pick a few solid toppings that go well together to make your meal way more pleasant to eat.
Sheetz lets you customize for a reason, but some combos just don’t work together. A chicken tender sub with honey mustard and mozzarella? Great.
That same sub with jalapeños, marinara, and avocado ranch?
Maybe slow down and rethink that one.
Skipping Through the Touchscreen Too Fast
The touchscreen menu is a Sheetz superpower, but customers mess it up by rushing through it.
Yeah, we all want to get our food fast, but when you just tap-tap-tap without reading, you miss out on some of the good stuff. You might not even realize you could’ve made that burger double-stacked or turned those fries into loaded fryz.
One of the best things about Sheetz is the crazy amount of control you get over your food.
You want a toasted pretzel bun instead of a regular roll? It’s on there.
Extra pickles, light mayo, no onions? Easy.
But you’ve gotta slow down and pay attention to the options or you’ll just end up with the default order.
Customers who take their time at the kiosk usually walk out with better food. You don’t have to scroll through every single thing like you’re reading a novel—just go at a steady enough pace so you don’t blow past the good stuff.
Not Checking Out the Limited-Time Items
Sheetz is always rolling out limited-time food that sounds like it came straight out of your dream journal.
For example, deep-fried pickle chips with ranch on the side, or Nashville hot sliders that show up for a few weeks and disappear.
Yeah, you blink and they’re gone.
But a lot of folks totally miss these specials because they stick with their same old order every time. Look, we get it—sometimes you just want your usual mac n cheese bites and a vanilla milkshake.
But if you never peek at the new stuff, you’re skipping over some pretty awesome eats.
Sheetz usually posts signs around the store or pops a banner up on the app, so just give it a quick look next time. You might find a new favorite.
And if it’s weird or wild? That’s the fun of it.
Ignoring the Sheetz App
Okay, if you’re still not using the Sheetz app, what are you doing? It’s seriously a game-changer.
Not only can you order ahead (which means skipping the line and walking in like a Sheetz VIP), but it also drops deals on free coffee, snacks, or BOGO hot dogs like it’s nothing.
Plus, the app remembers your go-to orders. So if you always get a buffalo chicken wrap with extra ranch and curly fryz on the side, you can just tap it again next time without building it from scratch.
Super handy when you’re hangry and don’t feel like thinking.
The best part?
You get points every time you use Sheetz’s app. And those points turn into freebies—like free drinks, chips, or even full-on meals.
Why leave free food on the table?
Forgetting to Use Your Sheetz Card or App for Points
This one hurts the most. Imagine getting a big MTO cheesesteak, a side of mozzarella sticks, and a smoothie—and then walking away without earning any points.
That’s food loyalty heartbreak right there.
If you’ve got the app or a physical Sheetz card, you’ve got to remember to scan it before you pay. Every purchase counts toward rewards, and it adds up faster than you’d think.
Even if you’re just grabbing a Dr. Pepper and a protien bar, it still earns points.
People forget all the time, especially if they’re in a rush. But if you make it a habit, you’ll hit those freebie rewards in no time.
And who doesn’t want another reason to visit Sheetz?
Not Checking Your Order Before Leaving
We all love Sheetz, but let’s be honest—sometimes things get mixed up. You order a spicy chicken sandwich and end up with a turkey club.
It happens. But it’s way more annoying when you find out after you’ve already driven off or made it home.
Before you leave the store, take a quick peek in your bag. Make sure your loaded totz didn’t turn into plain ones or your milkshake isn’t missing.
It only takes a second, and the staff is usually super chill about fixing things if there’s a mistake.
They’d rather fix it right away than have you come back mad or disappointed. So just double-check and save yourself the hassle.
Assuming Everything’s 24/7
Sheetz is known for being open all day and night, which is amazing when those late-night cravings hit.
But not every single item is available 24/7. The kitchen switches things up depending on the time of day, and some menu items are breakfast-only or limited to certain hours.
That big ol’ breakfast burrito?
You’re not getting it at 8 p.m.
And those afternoon-exclusive burger sliders?
Don’t expect to grab ‘em at 6 a.m.
A lot of customers think Sheetz’s menu never changes, and then they’re bummed when their usual item isn’t available.
Check the app or look at the in-store menu to see what’s being served when. It’ll save you from standing at the kiosk, confused and craving something that’s off the clock.
Only Ordering the Popular Stuff
Look, the classics are great—who doesn’t love a Sheetz hot dog with chili and cheese or a toasted sub with all the fixings? But Sheetz actually has a way bigger menu than most people realize.
Did you know you can get salads, smoothies, and even plant-based items?
A lot of folks stick to the same three things because that’s what they see other people order. But venturing outside the usual can lead to some seriously tasty finds.
The jalapeño poppers? Fire.
The cold-brew coffee? Surprisingly legit.
So next time you’re in there, scroll through some of the lesser-known categories. You might find a hidden gem that becomes your new go-to.
Not Asking for Help If You’re Confused
Sometimes the kiosk menus get a little overwhelming, especially if you’re new to Sheetz or just haven’t ordered something fancy before.
It’s totally fine to ask for help. The staff sees those screens all day, and most of them can walk you through it faster than you can figure it out on your own.
Customers sometimes get embarrassed or just wing it, and then they end up ordering something they didn’t mean to. Like getting plain fryz when they meant to get buffalo fryz with ranch and cheese sauce.
Big difference.
So don’t be shy. Ask questions. It saves everyone time when the order’s right the first time.
25 Discontinued Foods That Americans Miss Seeing on the Shelf
Every once in a while, big-name brands pull products with huge followings off the shelf, saddening Americans across the country. These are the foods Americans want back the most.
25 Discontinued Foods That Americans Miss Seeing on the Shelf
24 Old-Fashioned Candies That Need To Make a Comeback
From childhood classics to forgotten chocolates, these treats bring back memories of simpler times. Rediscover the joy of beloved confections that deserve to make a comeback.
