9 Precautions New Yorkers Should Take When Shopping at Wegmans
Wegmans is where you go for groceries, sure—but also for a little classic New York State joy.
Their fresh pasta section? Chef’s kiss. The bakery? Dangerous in the best way.
But even in this food wonderland, things can go sideways if you’re not a little prepared. From timing your trip to using the app like a pro, here are some low-stress ways to shop smarter, faster, and better at Wegmans.
Go When It’s Not Packed Like a Football Game
If you’ve ever tried to shop at Wegmans on a Sunday afternoon, you know it can feel like everyone within a 50-mile radius had the exact same idea. It’s like bumper cars with carts in the produce section.
So instead of grocery shopping on Sundays mid-morning or later, try hitting the store early in the morning on weekdays or later in the evening. Tuesday mornings, for example, are usually super low-key.
Shopping when it’s quieter also means better chances of snagging the good stuff.
Ever try finding those fresh-made crab cakes or sesame noodles from the prepared foods section during peak hours? Good luck. They disappear fast.
Early birds tend to score the best items before the crowds wipe the shelves clean.
Another bonus of off-peak shopping? The staff actually has time to help you. Want to know which smoked salmon is best for bagels?
Someone will actually stop and chat instead of speed-walking past you with a crate of avocados.
Double-Check for Recalls (Seriously)
We don’t think about food recalls until we hear about one, and then it’s like—yikes, that was in my fridge.
In January 2025, Wegmans had to recall a batch of their Family Pack Fully Cooked Breaded Chicken Breasts with Rib Meat because some had bits of bone in them. Not fun when you’re just trying to make chicken parm.
To stay in the loop, you can check the recalls section on the Wegmans website. It’s updated regularly, and they actually make it easy to understand what’s going on—no confusing lingo.
Or, if you use the app, it’ll even flag some of your past purchases if there’s an issue.
If you think you bought something sketchy, don’t toss it just yet. Wegmans has a solid return policy, and their customer service folks are great about getting you a refund or helping you figure out what to do next.
And, of course, it’s worth pointing out that food recalls aren’t Wegmans-specific—we dare you to name a grocery store that hasn’t had to recall an item.
Don’t Be a Cart Hog
Wegmans has wide aisles, but that doesn’t mean it’s OK to park your cart sideways like you own the place.
If you’re checking out the yogurt and can’t decide between Icelandic Provisions or Wegmans Greek with honey, pull your cart to the side—let other folks get by without doing a 12-point turn.
Same goes for leaving your cart in the middle of the aisle to run off and grab something. If you’re in the pasta section and you suddenly remember you need Wegmans Italian Classics Marinara, bring the cart with you.
That’s just basic cart courtesy.
And hey, when you’re all done, walk your cart back to the cart corral. It keeps the parking lot from turning into an obstacle course, and it saves employees time, too.
Let’s not make the poor person rounding up 30 loose carts in the rain work harder than they already are.
Don’t Forget to Bring a Cooler Bag
If you’re buying cold stuff—like Wegmans sushi or their insanely good chocolate peanut butter ice cream—it’s a smart move to bring a cooler bag. Especially in the summer.
Even a short drive home can turn frozen shrimp into a half-thawed mess if your car feels like an oven.
Wegmans has a lot of fresh and perishable goodies, and some of them don’t love sitting in a warm trunk. A soft cooler bag or insulated tote helps keep your milk cold, your chicken salad safe, and your frozen mac and cheese actually frozen.
You don’t need anything fancy—just something with insulation and maybe an ice pack or two.
They even sell cooler bags right at the checkout in most stores, just in case you forget yours.
Grab one, stash it in your trunk for future trips, and thank yourself later when your fresh mozzarella and prosciutto panini doesn’t come home soggy and sad.
Use the Wegmans App Like a Pro
That app? It’s a game-changer if you actually use it. You can build your shopping list right there, and the best part—it tells you exactly what aisle stuff is in.
No more wandering around for ten minutes looking for Wegmans Roasted Red Pepper Hummus like it’s a lost treasure.
You’ll also find digital coupons right in the app. There’s always a deal on stuff like their store-brand frozen veggies, oat milk, or those little fruit-on-the-bottom yogurts that are way better than they have any right to be.
Just tap to clip the ones you want before you go.
If you’re really short on time, Wegmans also has curbside pickup and delivery through the app. So if it’s pouring rain or you’re in sweatpants mode, you can still get everything from lettuce to a pint of chocolate chip cookie dough ice cream without ever stepping inside.
Self-Checkout? Read the Room
Self-checkout is great when you’ve got, like, a frozen pizza and a bottle of sparkling water. But if your cart’s bursting with enough groceries to feed a small army, head to a regular lane with a cashier.
It keeps the self-checkout lanes moving and saves you from the machine voice yelling “unexpected item in bagging area” over and over.
If you’re using reusable bags, make sure to set them down before you start scanning, or the system might get confused and pause your whole transaction.
Wegmans employees are super helpful, though, so just wave someone over if things go sideways.
Read the Signs (They’re Not Just for Decoration)
Wegmans puts up signs for a reason, and they’re usually super helpful. For example, if there’s a limit on how many packages of their hand-rolled sushi you can grab during a sale, the sign will say so.
Ignoring it and trying to walk out with eight trays of spicy tuna isn’t the move.
Same goes for store policies, like when seating at the café area is limited or temporarily closed. That’s not the staff being mean—it’s just safety stuff or store maintenance.
You’ll also see signs about digital-only deals or holiday hours, and those can save you time and money if you catch them before you shop.
If anything’s unclear, just ask. Seriously. Wegmans employees are usually super friendly and happy to help.
Whether you’re looking for tahini or wondering if the protein bars are still on sale, someone will point you in the right direction without making you feel silly.
Keep an Eye on Expiration Dates
Wegmans is great about rotating stock, but even the best stores can miss a few things—especially in the refrigerated and dairy sections.
If you’re grabbing something like their store-brand Greek yogurt, that tub way in the back might have a later expiration date than the one up front. Same goes for sliced deli meats, pre-packed salads, and even their famous guacamole.
It’s not just about getting the freshest stuff—it’s about giving yourself more time to eat it before it turns into a science experiment. No one wants to open a $7 tub of fresh mango salsa only to realize it expired two days ago.
Quick tip: flip the package over or check the bottom corners—Wegmans usually puts the date in easy-to-spot areas.
This goes double for anything in the ready-to-eat section. That sesame noodle bowl or buffalo chicken wrap might look amazing, but make sure you’re not grabbing one with a sell-by date of yesterday.
They’re made fresh, but they don’t last forever.
Don’t Sample Stuff That’s Not Free Samples
You know those gorgeous fruit displays near the entrance? They look tempting, but this isn’t a farmer’s market—don’t start munching on grapes like you’re taste-testing.
If it’s not labeled as a sample, it’s not a sample.
Sometimes Wegmans offers legit samples, like cubes of cave-aged cheddar or mini spoons of new ice cream flavors. Those are fair game, and honestly, they’re one of the best parts of the trip.
But opening a package of cookies before paying for them?
Yeah, not cool.
If you’re ever unsure whether something’s a sample, just ask a staff member. They’ll let you know, and sometimes they’ll even open something for you to try if you’re really curious about a new product.
That’s just another reason why Wegmans rocks.
25 Discontinued Foods That Americans Miss Seeing on the Shelf
Every once in a while, big-name brands pull products with huge followings off the shelf, saddening Americans across the country. These are the foods Americans want back the most.
25 Discontinued Foods That Americans Miss Seeing on the Shelf
The World’s 21 Priciest Food Items
Items such as caviar and truffles are commonly associated with opulence, but we bet you weren’t expecting some of the items on this list. From rare delicacies like moose milk cheese to unconventional treasures like black watermelon, the culinary world’s priciest offerings never fail to astonish.
