Two Finish Boxes Look the Same, but One Runs Out 14 Loads Sooner. New Jerseyans Hosting Thanksgiving Must Double-Check
You’ve got a house full of Thanksgiving dishes coming and one box of dishwasher pods to get through them.
From the shelf, the two boxes look like the same deal.
Here’s why same-size Finish dishwasher pod boxes can hold different counts, and what that means for New Jerseyans washing holiday dishes.
Note: This is general information, not financial advice. Prices and package counts are subject to change.
Mouseprint’s Target Sighting
The roundup lists the pair under the heading Finish Ultimate Dishwashing Pods.
At a Target store, the site’s author, who goes by MrConsumer, did a double-take at the Finish boxes.
The roundup adds that the larger package was cheaper.
A bigger count at a lower price leaves you paying less for each pod.
The roundup doesn’t say when the boxes were seen or what either one cost.
It also doesn’t say that Finish changed the size or contents of either box.
A national supermarket chain’s online listing was up on Oct. 17 for the Finish Ultimate box with 62 pods.
That listing offered the 62-count size and no other.
Per-Pod Math
The 62-pod box has 14 fewer pods than the 76-pod box.
That’s 18.4% fewer pods in a box the same size.
If both boxes sold at the same price, each pod in the smaller box would cost about 22.6% more.
That 22.6% is our arithmetic, and it holds only if the two boxes sell at the same price.
If the larger box sold for less, the difference would be wider than 22.6%.
Fewer units per box is the kind of size difference the Bureau of Labor Statistics accounts for in its Consumer Price Index.
The agency’s February 2023 article says its economists calculate an effective price for a standard size, usually a price per ounce.
In the agency’s example, a toilet paper roll that goes from 220 sheets to 200 shows a 10% price-per-sheet increase.
Dividing by the pod count follows the same logic.
What a Finish Pod Costs by the Box
Finish’s 62-count Ultimate box listed for $23.49 at one national supermarket chain in October 2026, or about 38 cents a pod.
At that same price, a 76-pod box would cost you about 31 cents a pod.
That’s about 7 cents less a pod, or about $5.30 for the 14 extra pods at the 62-pod box’s rate.
The 76-pod price is a what-if, not a shelf price.
Pod Counts at Target
Target’s product page for Finish Fresh Ultimate tablets lists 21, 57 and 70 counts, with no 62 or 76.
The sighting was at a Target store, so shelf counts there may differ from the online page.
The page shows the 21-count box at $8.99, or $1.06 an ounce, and gives no price for each pod.
That works out to about 43 cents a pod in October 2026.
That’s more per pod than the 38 cents for the 62-count box, though the prices come from different stores and possibly different product lines.
The page heading calls the product Finish Fresh Ultimate Dishwasher Detergent Tablets, while the page title says Finish Ultimate Quantum Dishwasher Detergent Pods.
In a reader reply, Mouseprint’s author warns that rolls from a warehouse club and a supermarket can differ in dimensions.
When counts differ from box to box, dividing the price by the count shows you what each pod costs.
Holiday Loads
A box lasts as many washes as it has pods, if you use one pod for each load.
On that math, the 76-pod box covers 76 loads, and the 62-pod box covers 62.
That leaves the smaller box 14 loads short.
Thanksgiving falls on Thursday, Nov. 26 in 2026, so a load a day from then on empties the smaller box two weeks sooner.
If you’re hosting and run two loads a day, the 62-pod box runs out about a week sooner.
New Jersey’s Unit-Price Rule
New Jersey’s unit-price rules aim to let shoppers compare retail prices of certain consumer commodities regardless of package size or quantity.
Stores with 4,000 square feet or less are exempt, whatever their yearly sales.
A single store with $2 million or less in yearly consumer-commodity sales is exempt too.
A commodity sold in one size only, and not comparable in form to any other product, is exempt as well.
The list names 46 commodities, each with an approved unit of measure.
The rules’ list of regulated products has an entry for detergents, soap and laundry products, with units that include a wash load.
The list doesn’t spell out dishwasher detergent, so check whether the tag in your store shows a price for each pod.
The code also treats any commodity missing from that list as exempt.
For commodities on the list, every size of the same commodity uses the same unit of measure.
Where a unit price falls below $1.00, the rules call for it to be shown in cents per unit.
Where a tag does carry a price for each pod or each wash load, you can compare boxes with different counts at a glance.
The Justia copy of the code carries a note that it may not be the most recent version.
Psst! How much do you know about reading package sizes? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.
Quiz
Shelf Smarts Quiz
Answer these questions on package sizes and unit prices. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?
Mouseprint’s January 2026 roundup reported that Charmin Ultra Soft mega rolls dropped from 224 sheets to how many?
Federal Rules on Package Size
The federal packaging law requires labels to disclose net contents.
It applies to consumer commodities other than food, drugs, therapeutic devices and cosmetics.
The law also authorizes rules on how packages characterize their sizes, to prevent consumer deception or to facilitate value comparisons.
It authorizes rules on slack fill of packages as well, a term food regulations define as the difference between a container's capacity and the volume of product in it.
4 Things North and South Jersey Can't Agree On, Starting With Breakfast Meat

New Jersey isn't big, but you'd hardly know it from the arguments.
People in the north and the south often answer the same everyday questions differently.
4 Things North and South Jersey Can't Agree On, Starting With Breakfast Meat
Gas Leads the 7 Everyday Costs That Climbed for New Jersey Households

Your wallet already knows prices went up.
But some everyday costs jumped far more than others, and many New Jersey households may feel them differently.
Gas Leads the 7 Everyday Costs That Climbed for New Jersey Households
