Bad News for Bay Area Californians Who Shop Safeway, Checkbook’s 150-Item Check Found
If you’re shopping for Thanksgiving dinner in the Bay Area, the store you pick could matter as much as the list you bring.
Here’s how much more Californians who shop Safeway pay than shoppers at WinCo, according to Checkbook’s Bay Area check.
Who Did the Pricing and How
Consumers’ Checkbook is a nonprofit that takes no advertising or referral fees, and its researchers shopped stores around the Bay Area with a 150-item list to compare prices.
Checkbook then measured each store against the all-store average, meaning the average at the other stores it surveyed.
A figure such as 31 percent means a store’s prices ran that far below that average.
That number covers price alone.
Quality came from a separate survey of Checkbook’s members, so you won’t find it in these price numbers.
Checkbook last updated the article in November 2025, so these figures may predate today’s shelf tags.
Checkbook’s comparison covers Bay Area supermarkets, so you shouldn’t read it as a price check for the rest of California.
Psst! How much do you know about supermarket history? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.
Quiz
Grocery Aisle IQ
Answer these questions on supermarket history and food labels. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?
When shoppers ignored the first shopping carts in the 1930s, what did the grocer behind them do about it?
WinCo at the Low End
WinCo's prices ran about 31 percent below the all-store average, the deepest discount Checkbook found.
Checkbook's example is a family that spends $300 a week at the supermarket.
At that 31 percent price difference, Checkbook puts the family's savings at $4,836 a year; by our math, that's about $93 a week.
Some stores charged nearly twice as much as others for the same products.
Quality doesn't fully explain it.
The gaps stayed enormous even on national-brand nonperishable items.
Safeway's prices averaged about 49 percent higher than WinCo's, which by our math turns $100 of WinCo groceries into about $149 at Safeway.
Flip it around, and by our math switching from Safeway to WinCo would cut the same bill by about a third, a gap worth noticing.
How Checkbook's 31 and 49 Percent Fit Together
The 49 percent compares Safeway with WinCo directly, so you can't add it to the 31 percent, which is measured against the all-store average.
Say a cart of groceries costs $100 at the all-store average. At WinCo's prices, the same cart would cost about $69.
Safeway's prices run 49 percent above WinCo's, so that cart would cost about $103 there.
That math is ours, built from Checkbook's two figures, so treat it as a rough guide.
Walmart, Grocery Outlet and Trader Joe's
Walmart, Grocery Outlet and Trader Joe's all landed 22 to 26 percent below the all-store average, while Safeway's prices averaged 39 percent higher than Walmart's.
The yearly and weekly figures below are our math, scaling Checkbook's $300-a-week example by each store's percentage.
Walmart's prices ran about 26 percent below the all-store average.
For that family, that works out to roughly $4,056 a year, or $78 a week.
Grocery Outlet came in about 23 percent below the average, with a mix of steeply discounted surplus national-brand products on its shelves.
For the same family, that's roughly $3,588 a year.
Trader Joe's is different.
Checkbook used a modified market basket to account for brand differences, and its prices ran about 22 percent below the all-store average.
By our math, that's roughly $3,432 a year for the same family, though the modified basket makes it a rougher estimate.
The chain sells mostly products under its label, so you won't find Coke, Heinz ketchup or Hellmann's mayo on its shelves.
Checkbook credits part of the savings to smaller-format stores with much lower overhead costs than conventional supermarkets.
If you shop there, you're trading the familiar brand lineup for comparable products at very low prices.
Stores 10 to 15 Percent Below Average
Unlike in most of the other metro areas where Checkbook publishes, most Bay Area shoppers live near at least a few low-cost supermarkets.
Target, FoodMaxx, FoodsCo, Smart & Final and Sprouts Farmers Market all charged between 10 and 15 percent less than the all-store average.
By our math, that range is roughly $1,560 to $2,340 a year, or $30 to $45 a week, for Checkbook's $300-a-week family.
WinCo's gap was bigger.
Safeway's prices averaged 16 percent higher than Target's, the closest comparison in this group.
You may already pass one of them on your way home.
Lucky, Nob Hill and Raley's
Lucky, Nob Hill, Raley's and Safeway priced about the same.
Raley's owns Nob Hill Foods.
Checkbook says these conventional chains did little to set themselves apart from one another on price, and it also calls them expensive.
Within each chain, prices at the Lucky, Safeway and Walmart locations Checkbook surveyed were about the same from store to store.
If you're weighing Whole Foods, its prices were just about average among the large chains Checkbook shopped, though slightly lower than Safeway's.
The chains that earned Checkbook's top quality ratings, such as Draeger's Market and Lunardi's, charged considerably higher prices than other area options.
Safeway's Side of the Gap
Safeway's prices averaged 39 percent higher than Walmart's in the survey, a smaller gap than the 49 percent against WinCo.
By our math, every $100 of groceries at Walmart's prices works out to about $139 at Safeway's.
Seen from Walmart's side, the same groceries cost roughly 28 percent less, by our math.
Target sat closer.
By our math, every $100 you'd spend at Target works out to about $116 at Safeway, or roughly 14 percent less at Target.
On quality, at least two-thirds of the customers who rated Safeway, Walmart or Target in Checkbook's member survey called that store less than “superior” overall.
8 Reasons Californians Say They're Done With the State in 2026

Ask a Californian how things are going, and the answer might be bad, with money at the heart of it.
Several recent polls help explain why some residents say they've had enough.
8 Reasons Californians Say They're Done With the State in 2026
8 California Rules That Change the Day You Register a Car From Another State

Driving a car into California is easy, but making it legal to keep there takes work.
California requires several steps for a car that's registered somewhere else, so know the rules before you start the paperwork.
8 California Rules That Change the Day You Register a Car From Another State
