8 Publix Bakery Orders Floridians Can Place Ahead for Thanksgiving

Somebody at the kids’ table is going to ask for something that isn’t pie.

Meanwhile, the grown-ups haven’t agreed on a flavor.

Here are the Publix bakery orders Floridians can place ahead for Thanksgiving to save the headache and keep everyone happy.

1. Apple Pie

Publix’s large apple pie is baked in-store with Crispin and Greening apples, cinnamon filling and a flaky crust.

It serves 8 to 9.

The listing requires 24 hours’ advance notice, and it tells you to call your Publix store if you need it sooner.

Publix calls it an award-winning pie.

A day’s notice is easy to give, so if your table expects apple, lock it in today.

2. Dutch Apple Pie

Publix’s Dutch apple pie uses the same Crispin and Greening apples, with cinnamon and a toasted streusel topping.

Publix’s bakery page says you can order it online and pick it up in-store the next day.

The Dutch apple pie listing also requires 24 hours’ advance notice.

The page also says its pies have won national awards.

Can’t decide between crust and crumb?

Order one of each.

3. Gobble Up the Cookie Cake

For the holiday, Publix lists a Gobble Up the Cookie Cake, a 12-inch chocolate chip cookie with a little turkey in buttercream.

The listing requires 24 hours’ advance notice.

Publix says pre-decorated designs like this one allow only limited customizations.

It’s decorated with fudge and frosting.

If you need it sooner, call your Publix store.

Cute and edible.

Publix’s listing pitches it for the kids’ table.

4. Decorated Cookie Cake

Publix’s cookie cakes are 12-inch chocolate chip cookies, according to its product listings.

The listing requires 24 hours’ advance notice and tells you to call your store if you need it sooner.

Choose it for a plain cookie with no theme.

Keep it simple.

Psst! Is your Thanksgiving dessert order ready to go? Run through this checklist and see where you stand.

Thanksgiving Bakery Order Check

Tick each one that’s true for you.

5. Chantilly Cake

Publix’s Chantilly Cake has three layers of vanilla almond cake, seedless raspberry filling and glazed berries. Mascarpone Chantilly dessert cream and whipped vanilla topping finish it.

You can order a round cake, a quarter sheet or a half sheet. The listing requires 24 hours’ advance notice.

If you’re feeding a crowd, check the half sheet first.

Pick your size.

6. Chocolate-Covered Strawberry Platter

Publix lists a 21-count medium chocolate-covered strawberry platter.

You get five varieties, including plain, crushed cookies and chocolate crispie trio sprinkles.

It serves 10 to 15, and the listing requires 24 hours’ advance notice.

Feeding a bigger table?

Plan on a second platter.

7. Decadent Sweets Platter

Publix’s bakery page says its Decadent Sweets Platter comes with brownies, cheesecake bites, miniature cannoli, chocolate-covered strawberries and vanilla buttercream sandwiches.

Five treats, one tray.

The bakery says you can order its platters online for in-store pickup as soon as 24 hours before your event.

The page calls it one of its most popular selections.

Pick this one if your table can’t agree on a dessert.

8. Custom Cake

Publix’s bakery lets you design a custom cake online and pick it up in-store the next day.

Your flavor options include vanilla, chocolate, marble, carrot and red velvet.

You can add a message of up to 50 characters. That’s room to write a full Happy Thanksgiving.

Write it yourself.

If a pie and a platter don’t feel like enough for your table, a custom cake fills the gap.

Matching Servings to Your Guest List

A little arithmetic sorts out how much to order.

Do the math.

A large apple pie serves 8 to 9, and a round Chantilly Cake serves 6 to 8, according to their listings.

Together, they cover 14 to 17 guests.

A quarter sheet Chantilly Cake serves 15 to 20 by itself, and a half sheet serves 35 to 40.

The 21-count strawberry platter serves 10 to 15, so it works well as an add-on.

Pair a round Chantilly Cake with that platter, and you’ve covered roughly 16 to 23 guests.

Add a Dutch apple pie, and that grows to roughly 24 to 32.

Publix’s Notice Times for Dinner Orders

The holiday meals page says Publix needs at least 48 hours before pickup.

It also says you should try to order at least three days before your holiday feast.

Florida Today reports that the last day to order a Thanksgiving dinner is Nov. 23.

Breads and Rolls to Add to Your Pickup

Publix’s bakery page says it bakes over a dozen scratch-made breads in-store every day.

Its bakers use the same methods the chain has used in its bakeries for more than 50 years, according to the page.

The named breads include Tutto Pugliese, Italian Five Grain Bread, sourdough round, White Mountain Bread, Chicago hard rolls and Cuban bread.

If you order a holiday dinner with rolls or a pie, the holiday meals page says you may need to stop by the Bakery as well.

Plan the stop once.

Notice Times at a Glance

Here’s how Publix’s notice times line up.

The apple pie, the Dutch apple pie, the Gobble Up cookie cake and the decorated cookie cake each carry a 24-hour notice on their listings.

So do the Chantilly Cake and the strawberry platter.

The custom cake is a next-day online order, according to the bakery’s design page.

The Decadent Sweets Platter can be ordered as soon as 24 hours before your event.

Choose one pickup day for everything, and the whole list is a single stop.

Sort your list.

Seasonal Cakes to Ask About

Florida Today lists a Caramel Apple Crunch Cake among Publix’s 2026 Thanksgiving offerings.

It also lists a Golden Amaretto Almond Cake, which it calls new this year.

Worth a question.

The same report puts Wednesday, Nov. 25 as the final pickup date for Thanksgiving dinners.

The listings give a notice time, not a cutoff date. Ordering before Nov. 23 keeps you ahead of the dinner deadline.

Your store can tell you whether either cake takes a pickup order.

13 Things Many Floridians Have Done at Publix at Least Once

Image Credit: Wirestock Creators / Shutterstock.com.

Some Publix habits are so automatic you don’t even notice them anymore.

See how many of these you’ve done at least once.

13 Things Many Floridians Have Done at Publix at Least Once

GreenWise Doesn’t Always Mean Organic at Publix. 5 Other Shelf Labels Floridians Mix Up

Image Credit: Eric Glenn / Shutterstock.com.

Grocery shelves are covered in little tags, and many shoppers skim right past them.

Here’s what a handful of Publix shelf tags promise.

GreenWise Doesn’t Always Mean Organic at Publix. 5 Other Shelf Labels Floridians Mix Up

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *