6 Things New York’s Scanner Law Says About a Price That Rings Up Wrong

Checking your receipt before you leave the store is right up there with flossing: most of us mean to.

With Thanksgiving next week and your cart about to get fuller, now is a good time to start.

Here’s what New York’s scanner law says about a price that rings up wrong.

Note: This is general information, not legal advice. Pricing rules and penalties are subject to change, so confirm the current requirements with the New York State Department of Agriculture and Markets.

1. Lowest Posted Price

Under the scanner law, whether your total is an overcharge depends on what the law treats as the price.

It defines the retail price as the lowest advertised, written, posted or marked price of an item.

Say your shelf tag reads $4.29 and the weekly ad reads $3.99.

Under that wording, a register that charges you $4.29 has charged you more than the retail price.

Here, $3.99 is the benchmark.

Which Stores the Scanner Law Covers

The scanner law applies to a retail store, which it defines as a store that sells items directly to consumers and charges or is liable for collecting sales tax.

That covers stores that use barcode scanners or price-look-up codes at checkout, and stores that price items by hand.

By that definition, a pharmacy or hardware store qualifies as readily as a supermarket.

2. The Price on Your Receipt

When a store’s checkout system sets the price, the scanner law counts the price on the receipt you get after the final total as the price you were charged.

That makes your receipt the place where an overcharge shows up.

The store has to make that price equal to the retail price.

So before you bag anything, compare the receipt with the shelf tag and the ad.

3. Large Overcharge Line

New York’s scanner law doesn’t treat every wrong price alike, and it sets clear thresholds for what counts as a large overcharge.

On an item priced up to $2.50, an error of 25 cents counts as large.

Above $2.50, the line is an error of 10%.

If your $2 can of beans rings up at $2.30, that’s 30 cents too much, which crosses it.

If your $20 roast is charged at $23, that’s 15% too much, which crosses it too.

A large overcharge on even a single item is one of the situations where the law lets officials impose a civil penalty on the store.

4. Two Percent Sample Rule

Your receipt isn’t the only way a wrong price can come to light under the scanner law.

Inspectors check a random sample of a store’s items.

A store of at least 300 square feet is deemed in compliance if 98% of the sampled items are accurately priced.

That sounds strict until you look at the other side of it.

A civil penalty for sampled overcharges is allowed only when more than 2% of the items are overcharged.

In a sample of 100 items, three overcharges would cross that line, and two wouldn’t.

If you’re wondering what a store risks, fines top out at $300 per violation at its first inspection of the calendar year.

At a second or later inspection that year, the cap rises to $600 per violation.

Psst! How much do you know about price checks at the register? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.

Quiz

New York Price Check IQ

Answer these questions on checkout prices, scanners and who checks them in New York. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 9

What’s the longest an item can be on sale and still skip New York City’s individual price tag rule?

5. Posted Refund Policy

Any store covered by the scanner law has to post its refund policy for overcharges in a conspicuous place.

If your receipt is off, the posted policy is the first thing to read before you head to customer service.

A store that skips the posting can face a civil penalty for that alone.

6. Complaints and Inspections

If you complain about an overcharge, the scanner law lets officials inspect the individual items involved.

An overcharge that an inspector verifies after a complaint is a listed ground for a civil penalty.

The state's directory lists your local weights and measures department, which is the place to start.

Uneven County Testing

How often anyone tests the prices at your store depends on your county, and a 2024 audit by the state Comptroller shows how much that can vary.

Of the 10 county departments it audited, five didn't perform a single price accuracy test between January 2022 and September 2023.

If your store is in Nassau, Seneca, Tompkins, Washington or Wyoming County, that county's department was one of the five.

Jefferson and Niagara tested regularly and found some products scanning 20 to 31% above the marked price.

One county department tested prices only when it received a consumer complaint, which means a consumer had to speak up first.

Local Pricing Laws

If a store near you overcharges you, the scanner law may not be the one that applies.

A city or county that already had a pricing law when the state law took effect can keep enforcing it.

Until that local law is repealed, the state law has no force there.

So the same overcharge can be handled under different rules in two neighboring places.

Places without an older local law are supposed to adopt the state's pricing accuracy provisions.

In that audit's 10 counties, only Greene had a local law on price accuracy testing.

New York City Shopper Advice

On top of the state scanner law, New York City's Department of Consumer and Worker Protection tells you to check your receipt against the advertised price.

Its reasoning is that a computerized system isn't always accurate.

Many stores in the city also have to put the price on an individual label, stamp or tag on each item, with some exceptions.

City stores must honor their advertised prices too, so a register total above the ad is worth questioning.

9 Things Downstate New Yorkers Say About Upstate That Locals Are Sick Of

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

A family from Long Island checks into a bed-and-breakfast near Cornell University and asks how far away the nearest college town is.

The owner just blinks, and that's only the start of what upstate locals are tired of hearing.

9 Things Downstate New Yorkers Say About Upstate That Locals Are Sick Of

9 Things New York Landlords Can't Do, No Matter What Your Lease Says

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

A lease can run pages, and it's easy to skim past a line or two.

A few of those lines may matter less than the fine print makes them sound.

9 Things New York Landlords Can't Do, No Matter What Your Lease Says

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *