5 Online Grocery Costs Pennsylvanians Don’t See on the Shelf Tag

Ordering your groceries online can save you an hour in the store, but it can also add dollars to your bill that you’d never pay at the register.

With a Thanksgiving-sized order, those extra dollars can grow along with your cart.

These are the online grocery costs Pennsylvanians shopping in person never see on the shelf tag.

1. Wegmans’ 15% Markup

A $6 box of cereal on the shelf comes to about $6.90 in your Wegmans online cart.

Wegmans’ online grocery prices run about 15% above its in-store prices, whether you pick up or have the order delivered.

Wegmans says that markup covers the cost of shopping your order.

If you build a full Thanksgiving list, the cart can come to about 15% more than the same items cost in the aisle.

Wegmans’ FAQ names no state exception, so the markup applies at its stores across Pennsylvania too.

2. The Giant Company’s $7.95 Delivery Fee

Delivery from The Giant Company costs $7.95 at its Hatfield, York and Allentown stores.

Giant also sets a $60 minimum order for delivery, so a smaller cart can’t be delivered.

Pickup doesn’t have that problem.

Those pages list pickup as free, with a $0 minimum.

The store pages also say additional charges and applicable sales tax may apply in certain areas.

If you order delivery often, the same pages pitch Giant’s Choice Pass for unlimited free delivery and pickup, so check its price before you sign up.

3. Weis’ Pickup Fee Under $100

Weis Markets, the Pennsylvania chain based in Sunbury, charges $4.95 for grocery pickup on orders under $100.

If your order reaches $100, Weis waives the fee.

A dollar short costs $4.95.

Weis personal shoppers don’t accept tips, so you can skip that math.

Psst! How much do you know about Pennsylvania’s food scene? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.

Quiz

Pennsylvania Food IQ

Answer these questions on Pennsylvania food, markets and sandwiches. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 8

An apprentice pharmacist in which Pennsylvania town is credited with inventing the banana split in 1904?

4. Wegmans' Long-Distance and Heavy-Order Fees

Wegmans fulfills online delivery through Instacart, and the FAQ says Instacart adds a long-distance fee when you order 30 to 60 minutes from a store.

The fee applies whether or not you have an Instacart+ membership.

The FAQ also lists a bag fee and a heavy order fee, and it puts no dollar amount on any of the three fees.

If you live a long drive from the nearest Wegmans, budget for the long-distance fee.

5. Aldi's Service Fee and Default Tip

Aldi sets the default tip on Instacart delivery orders at 10%, though Aldi curbside shoppers don't accept tips at all.

A 10% tip on a $100 order is $10, and the FAQ lets you pick 5% or 15% instead.

Delivery can also add a service fee and a small fee for bags, with no dollar amount listed for either.

Curbside orders carry a small pickup fee and a small fee for bags, also without a dollar amount.

If you add a tip, your total can rise above what the same items add up to on the shelf.

The FAQ also says online prices may vary slightly from in-store prices in your area.

Aldi says nearly 1500 of its stores across 38 states offer curbside pickup, but its FAQ never names the states.

Enter your ZIP code to see whether your Aldi offers curbside pickup or delivery.

Wegmans' $4.99 Delivery Promotion

Through Dec. 31, 2026, Wegmans waives service fees and cuts standard delivery costs to $4.99, though taxes and a tip still apply.

Wegmans' page adds that the offer is subject to change, so check the price before you place your order.

Pickup skips the delivery fee, service charge and tip, Wegmans' FAQ says.

A $10 order minimum still applies to pickup.

A $100 Wegmans Order Online

A Wegmans grocery order that totals $100 at shelf prices grows in two steps online.

The first step is the markup, which takes those same items to about $115.

The second is the $4.99 promotional delivery fee, which puts you near $120 before taxes, tip and any bag, heavy order or long-distance fee.

That's about 20% more than the shelf total.

Fees Instacart+ Doesn't Waive

An Instacart+ membership doesn't erase every Aldi cost, since service fees and optional delivery tips may still apply.

The $0 delivery and curbside fees apply to orders over $35 that Instacart fulfills.

A $20 top-up order misses that cutoff.

Wegmans lets you link an existing Instacart+ membership to your account, and Instacart still bills you for the membership directly.

Wegmans' FAQ lists its regular delivery fee for shoppers without an Instacart+ membership, with no dollar amount.

SNAP and Online Fees

Pennsylvania's Department of Human Services says you can't pay delivery fees or driver tips with Supplemental Nutrition Assistance Program (SNAP) benefits when you order groceries online.

You pay fees and other ineligible items with another payment method, so keep a debit or credit card handy.

Wegmans takes electronic benefit transfer (EBT) SNAP cards for online orders, but its EBT FAQ still requires a primary payment method for non-EBT-eligible items and fees.

If you add EBT-eligible items after you place an order, your credit card pays for them unless you adjust the EBT amount before shopping starts.

Weis lets you pay at pickup with E.B.T., cash, a check or a Weis gift card.

Pricier Substitutes

Wegmans can offer a replacement when an item in your online order runs low at the store.

If the replacement costs more than the item you ordered, you'll be charged more.

Wegmans' FAQ says you can choose your replacements after you place your order.

You can approve the replacement shown or search for a different item yourself.

9 Aldi Mistakes Pennsylvania Shoppers Over 60 Make Every Week

Image Credit: Deutschlandreform / Shutterstock.com.

Aldi has habits your hometown supermarket didn't teach you.

If you get the habits wrong, you either walk out poorer or leave the best stuff behind.

9 Aldi Mistakes Pennsylvania Shoppers Over 60 Make Every Week

8 Things Pennsylvania Grocery Cashiers Notice About You Within 10 Seconds

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

You might think your grocery run is a private affair.

Your cashier probably disagrees, and the clues start before you swipe your card.

8 Things Pennsylvania Grocery Cashiers Notice About You Within 10 Seconds

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *