6 Precautions Wisconsinites Over 65 Should Take When Shopping at Pick ‘n Save

Turning 65 comes with a Medicare card, a mailbox full of plan brochures and the right to tell younger shoppers what a gallon of milk used to cost.

It also comes with more to think about at the grocery store than you might expect.

Here are the precautions Wisconsinites over 65 should take when shopping at Pick ‘n Save.

Note: This is general information, not medical or financial advice. Medicare rules, benefit amounts and deadlines are subject to change, so confirm the current details with Medicare.

1. Your Plan’s Preferred Pharmacies

Pick ‘n Save has 45 pharmacies across 40 cities in Wisconsin, and whether yours gives you the lower price depends on your Medicare plan.

Pick ‘n Save says it offers preferred pricing on most Medicare plans, but not every plan available in your area.

A preferred pharmacy is a part of your plan’s network that can cost you less than other in-network pharmacies.

AARP cites a study that found people who fill at a preferred pharmacy could save $2 to $15 on each generic fill.

That adds up fast on a monthly prescription.

Fill at a pharmacy outside your plan’s network, and you’ll most likely pay more.

Ask the counter whether it’s in-network for your plan, and whether it’s preferred.

It costs nothing to ask.

Pick ‘n Save’s pharmacy page also has a “See Accepted Plans” button.

Open Enrollment ends December 7, and whatever you change by then takes effect January 1.

Before you pick a plan for next year, make sure Pick ‘n Save is on its pharmacy list.

You can check each plan’s in-network and preferred pharmacies, or use Medicare’s plan-finding tool.

December 7 falls on a Monday this year, so the weekend of December 5 and 6 is your last weekend to sort it out.

Psst! How much do you know about Wisconsin groceries and pharmacies? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.

Quiz

Wisconsin Grocery Trivia

Answer these questions on Wisconsin groceries, pharmacies and Kroger history. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 8

Why do fresh Wisconsin cheese curds squeak when you bite them?

2. Vaccine Billing

Before you roll up your sleeve at Pick 'n Save's pharmacy, find out which part of Medicare is paying for your shot.

The pharmacy offers flu, respiratory syncytial virus (RSV) and COVID vaccines in-store, though availability varies by location and age restrictions may apply.

Part B covers flu and COVID shots, while Part D covers RSV and shingles shots.

Part B flu and COVID shots cost you nothing if the provider accepts assignment, and you pay nothing for the shingles shot if you have Part D.

Get a Part D shot from a provider outside your plan's network, and you may pay the administration fee on the spot, then ask your plan to pay you back.

Nobody needs a surprise fee on top of a sore arm.

Pick 'n Save also has a page for the shingles vaccine for adults 50 and older, though availability varies by location, so call ahead before you plan around a shot.

It also tells you to consult your health insurance company about coverage, so bring your Medicare and plan cards.

3. Prescription Payment Plan

A big prescription can land at the Pick 'n Save pharmacy counter all at once, and Medicare's payment plan can turn that bill into monthly payments.

If you join the Medicare Prescription Payment Plan, you won't pay your Pick 'n Save pharmacy for covered Part D drugs.

Your plan bills you each month instead.

You join by calling your plan or visiting its website.

You can join at any time of year, but Medicare says the plan may not be the best choice late in the calendar year, after September.

It's late in the calendar year now, so that caution applies to you.

Pick 'n Save and Your Part D Cap

What you spend at the Pick 'n Save pharmacy counter on covered Part D drugs counts toward Medicare's yearly out-of-pocket cap.

That cap is $2,100 in 2026 and $2,400 in 2027.

Certain payments made on your behalf count too, like through the Extra Help program.

The cap applies whether or not you join the payment plan.

The payment plan only spreads your costs out.

It doesn't save you money or lower your drug costs.

4. Gift Card Scams

Pick 'n Save sells gift cards for brands like Outback and Home Depot, and scammers sometimes stay on the phone with you while you shop for one.

No legitimate business or government agency will ever tell you to buy a gift card to pay them.

Only scammers do that.

Hang up.

Federal Trade Commission figures show adults 60 and older reported losing $2.4 billion to fraud in 2024, up from about $600 million in 2020.

Wisconsin's Department of Agriculture, Trade and Consumer Protection has warned about a second risk before you ever reach the register.

Thieves scan cards, scratch off security codes and drain the funds after you buy.

Buy only cards that are fully enclosed in packaging, check the barcode for a sticker, and tell the seller if a card looks tampered with.

If you've already bought a card for a scammer, report it to the gift card company right away and ask for your money back.

5. Medicare Advantage Benefit Cards

Pick 'n Save may or may not take your Medicare Advantage benefit card because the card works only at stores in its network.

Find that out from your plan, not at the register with a full cart and a line behind you.

Kroger, the company that owns Pick 'n Save, launched a Smart Benefits program with Soda Health in December 2023.

The program lets members of participating Medicare Advantage plans use benefits at Kroger's family of pharmacies on eligible food and over-the-counter health items.

Your plan decides which items count.

A grocery allowance is pickier: AARP says it's available only to Medicare Advantage members with certain chronic conditions.

Most of these allowances don't roll over.

Funds usually expire on December 31, though some expire at the end of a quarter or a month.

This year, December 31 lands five weeks after Thanksgiving, so a balance you ignore through the holidays will probably be gone.

Pain relievers, vitamins, cold and allergy medicine and first aid supplies are the usual over-the-counter items, so a winter stock-up is an easy way to spend a balance down.

6. SeniorCare at the Counter

Wisconsin's SeniorCare program helps residents 65 or older pay for prescription drugs and vaccines, so your Pick 'n Save pharmacist is the one to ask whether the pharmacy participates.

Over 95% of pharmacies in Wisconsin participate in the program, so odds are good yours does.

SeniorCare is the payer of last resort, so your pharmacy should bill Medicare first and SeniorCare second.

That order matters.

SeniorCare only picks up what your other insurance leaves behind.

Bring your Part D and SeniorCare cards, and ask whether the pharmacy has your SeniorCare information on file.

You can also show your SeniorCare card in the MyACCESS mobile app.

SeniorCare enrollment costs $30 per person each year.

You'll get a renewal application about six weeks before your enrollment ends, and if you don't renew, you'll have to apply again.

SeniorCare customer service, at 800-657-2038, is the number to call if your card hasn't arrived within two weeks of your enrollment letter.

8 Aldi Mistakes Wisconsinites Repeat Every Week

Image Credit: TTL Deez / Shutterstock.com.

One missing quarter can leave you patting down every pocket beside a locked cart outside a Wisconsin Aldi.

That's one of several easy mistakes at the checkout lane, and a few of them cost shoppers more than a quarter.

8 Aldi Mistakes Wisconsinites Repeat Every Week

6 Wisconsin Supper Club Habits Nobody Explains to Newcomers

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

The Wisconsin supper club runs on a slow dinner, a stiff drink and house rules nobody hands out-of-staters at the door.

A few of these habits are worth learning before your first reservation.

6 Wisconsin Supper Club Habits Nobody Explains to Newcomers

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *