Have Mayflower Ancestors? 4 Massachusetts Records That Can Actually Prove It

If you’re hoping a DNA kit will settle your family’s Mayflower story, it won’t get you as far as you’d think.

The real proof is sitting in Massachusetts offices and archives.

These are the Massachusetts records that can actually prove your Mayflower ancestry.

1. Plymouth Colony Transcripts

The Massachusetts Archives holds transcripts of Plymouth Colony’s records from 1620 to 1691.

The Archives’ description says the set includes legislative, court, financial and vital records, plus deeds and wills.

The Mayflower Society’s guidance lists wills among the documents a Mayflower application can use as proof.

The Commonwealth transcribed the records in the 19th century and left the originals in Plymouth.

Twelve volumes of the transcripts are on Archive.org, including court orders, judicial acts, laws and deeds.

A deed or court order that names a family may help tie one generation to the next.

Few records survive from the colony’s first ten years, so the paper trail for 1620 itself is thin.

Because these are transcripts, check any entry your line depends on against the original.

2. Plymouth County Registry of Deeds

The Registry of Deeds in Plymouth County has images of its Plymouth Colony deed records from 1620 to 1685 on its website.

Each of those colony deed books has an index in its last pages, and the Registry also lists the Mayers’ Index to Plymouth Colony Land Deeds as a companion finding aid.

For later deeds, its grantor and grantee indexes run from 1686, and its record books from Book 1 (1686) are online too.

When you apply, land records are among those a Massachusetts Mayflower society’s guidance names as commonly used after birth, marriage and death records.

Psst! How much do you know about the Mayflower and Plymouth Colony? Take our quiz and see how many you can get right.

Quiz

Pilgrim Trivia

Answer these questions on the Mayflower, Plymouth Colony and the first harvest feast. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 10

In March 1621, a visitor walked alone into Plymouth and greeted the colonists in English. What did he ask them for?

3. Town Clerk Records

Statewide collection of vital records didn't start until 1841, so records for a Mayflower line in the 1700s can come from town offices.

Some Massachusetts city and town records go back to 1635.

Freetown's clerk holds records from 1683 to 1840, and those pre-1841 records exist only in that office.

A genealogy request there takes the person's name, an approximate date and the kind of record, whether a birth, a marriage or a death.

A certified copy of a pre-1841 record costs $10.

Plymouth's clerk has an online database of the town's vital records to the year 1850, and a certified copy of any record in it comes from contacting the office.

Search the town where your ancestor lived, not the town where you live now.

When a Clerk Has No Record

An American Ancestors class handout on the Mayflower Society's application says an applicant must provide proof that a missing record was sought and not found.

That proof usually takes the form of a "No Record Found" letter from the state, county or town clerk.

Church records, gravestone photos, family Bibles and censuses are among the other documents the handout lists as possible proof.

4. State Vital Records

The Massachusetts Archives holds statewide births, marriages and deaths from 1841 through 1935.

Those years may cover your great-grandparents' births, marriages and deaths.

Free scans of many of those records, from 1841 through 1930, are on FamilySearch.org.

If you can't find a record there, the Archives takes email requests for images of up to five unique records.

Certified copies cost $3 each, payable by cash or check, with a limit of five certificates per order.

The Archives says orders can take 20-plus weeks.

You can visit the Archives in Boston without an appointment, but calling ahead may save time, and photo identification is required.

Some towns hold copies of those years too, and the price gap shows: Hanover charges $10 for a certified 1841 to 1930 copy, against $3 from the Archives.

Records from 1936 forward come from the Registry of Vital Records and Statistics.

Bradford's Passenger List

A Mayflower line has to end at a passenger.

The State Library of Massachusetts keeps William Bradford's handwritten history of Plymouth, which includes a list of passengers on the Mayflower.

The Mayflower had 102 passengers.

The manuscript returned to Massachusetts in 1897, and the State Library keeps it today.

A digitized version of the original is available to download, and visitors can view a facsimile volume at the library in Boston.

Special Collections is open Monday through Wednesday, 9 a.m. to 5 p.m., and advance appointments are highly recommended.

A name on that list shows that a person sailed.

It doesn't show that you descend from that person.

Not every passenger left descendants, either, and the Mayflower Society says 51 passengers are known to have had children.

Mayflower Society Review

Membership in the General Society of Mayflower Descendants requires proof of direct lineal descent from a Mayflower passenger.

The Society wants documents that prove the events and relationships within and between each generation.

In most cases, it says, the first five generations are already proven in its Mayflower Families books, known as the Silver Books.

A Massachusetts Mayflower society's documentation guidance asks for long-form birth, marriage and death records for the line carrier and spouse, when those records are available.

The Massachusetts Society of Mayflower Descendants' Historian compares your lineage against all previously submitted applications and reviews the documents you supply.

From application to acceptance takes six to twelve months there, depending on how complex the application is.

DNA Evidence

A DNA test won't stand in for the records above when you apply to the Mayflower Society.

The Society's DNA policy, modified in April 2024, lets DNA support the parent-child connection for only one successive generation.

The policy requires a full standard paper trail in the application for every generation that doesn't use DNA.

Where traditional documentation is missing, as with sealed adoptions, the policy allows DNA evidence as part of an in-depth research report.

7 Things Bay Staters Do That Make No Sense South of Hartford

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

You probably don't think twice about half of what you say and do as a Bay Stater.

Someone from farther south might.

7 Things Bay Staters Do That Make No Sense South of Hartford

12 Things Bay Staters Call by Names That Much of America Doesn't Use

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Some words feel so normal at home that you forget they're local.

Bay Staters use a few names without a second thought, and visitors to Massachusetts may need a translation.

12 Things Bay Staters Call by Names That Much of America Doesn't Use

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *