11 New York Restaurants Everyone Misses but Nobody Can Bring Back
New York City loses restaurants every week, and few people mourn them.
A few, though, took a piece of the city with them when they closed.
No amount of money or nostalgia has been able to bring these restaurants back.
1. Windows on the World
Windows on the World sat on the 107th floor of the World Trade Center’s North Tower.
You didn’t go for the food so much as the feeling of dining a quarter-mile above Manhattan.
On a clear night, the whole city glittered under your wine glass.
It was lost on September 11, 2001, along with 72 of its workers who were there that morning.
No view in New York has taken its place, and none ever will.
2. The Four Seasons
The Four Seasons opened inside the Seagram Building in 1959 and more or less invented the power lunch.
Executives cut deals in the Grill Room while the Pool Room shimmered next door.
A Picasso hung on the wall, and the menu changed with the seasons long before that was fashionable.
The lease ran out in 2016, and the rooms that made it magic stayed behind.
A revival a few blocks away didn’t take.
3. Lutèce
For forty years, Lutèce was the French restaurant other French restaurants measured themselves against.
Chef André Soltner ran the kitchen on East 50th Street and often greeted diners at the door himself.
Jackie Onassis ate there. So did anyone who could land a table.
Soltner cooked in that kitchen for some three decades, an eternity by restaurant standards.
By 2004, tastes had drifted, and Lutèce closed for good.
You can’t rebuild a room that ran on one chef’s hands.
4. Carnegie Deli
Carnegie Deli piled pastrami so high you needed a plan, not just an appetite.
Tourists and cab drivers crowded its Seventh Avenue tables for 79 years.
The cheesecake alone was worth the wait at the door.
Woody Allen even framed his film “Broadway Danny Rose” around comedians swapping stories at its tables.
The Midtown flagship closed in 2016, and a short comeback couldn’t bottle the old magic.
Some sandwiches only taste right under crowded fluorescent lights.
5. Horn & Hardart Automat
Before fast food, New York ate at the Automat.
You dropped nickels into a wall of little glass doors and pulled out mac and cheese or a slice of pie.
Horn & Hardart fed the whole city this way for decades, no waiter required.
The last one closed in 1991, beaten by burger chains and changing tastes.
Every so-called modern automat since has just been a vending machine with better lighting.
6. The ’21’ Club
The ’21’ Club started as a Prohibition speakeasy and never lost the swagger.
Painted jockey statues lined the balcony, and a hidden wine cellar guarded bottles for presidents and movie stars.
You wore a jacket, or they found you one.
Hollywood loved it too, and the bar turned up in films from “All About Eve” to “Wall Street.”
After 90 years, it closed in 2020 and hasn’t reopened.
The jockeys came down, and a piece of old New York went with them.
Quiz
NYC Food IQ
Nine questions on the dishes and firsts that New York gave the world. We bet you can’t run the table. Care to try?
7. Toots Shor's
Toots Shor's was less a restaurant than a clubhouse for the city's biggest names.
Sinatra, DiMaggio, and Jackie Gleason held court while Toots himself needled the regulars he loved.
The round bar in the middle was the beating heart of the city's sports scene.
Tax troubles and changing times shut it down by the mid-1970s.
Nobody builds a saloon like that anymore, and they couldn't if they tried.
8. Le Cirque
Le Cirque brought circus-bright glamour to French dining starting in 1974.
Owner Sirio Maccioni worked the room like a maestro, and a good table meant you'd arrived.
The crème brûlée and the pasta primavera turned into New York classics.
Rising rent finally closed it on the first day of 2018.
The sparkle didn't carry over to whatever came next.
9. Café des Artistes
Café des Artistes hid just off Central Park West, wrapped in murals of frolicking nymphs.
It was the spot for an anniversary, a proposal, or a long lunch that bled into dinner.
The painted walls made every table feel like a shared secret.
It closed in 2009 after nearly a century.
The murals were saved. The candlelit hush around them was not.
10. Lüchow's
Lüchow's poured German beer and oompah music on 14th Street for a full century.
Opened in 1882, it served sauerbraten and venison under dark wood and mounted antlers.
Diamond Jim Brady and half of old New York ate their fill there.
At its peak the place sat hundreds of diners across a maze of grand halls.
A move to the Theater District sank it, and it closed in 1982.
The original room couldn't be packed up and carried uptown.
11. Elaine's
Elaine's was never about the food, and everybody knew it.
Writers, actors, and the odd ballplayer packed the Upper East Side tables while Elaine Kaufman ruled the room.
Woody Allen filmed there, and a regular table counted as a kind of status.
When Elaine died, the place couldn't outlive her, and it closed in 2011.
A bar like that lives and dies with its owner.
A handful of these names still flicker on a faded sign or in a museum case, and a couple sell T-shirts to tourists who never ate there.
But Lüchow's antlers, the Automat's nickel doors, and Elaine's corner table only worked in their own rooms on their own nights, and those don't come back.
14 Squatter's Rights Rules That Catch New York Landlords Off Guard
You own a building in New York, and one day someone's living in it without your okay.
Now what?
The rules around squatters trip up even seasoned owners, and one wrong move can cost months in court.
14 Squatter's Rights Rules That Catch New York Landlords Off Guard
13 Things New York Taxes That Other States Don't
New York has a reputation for taxing everything, and new arrivals still get blindsided.
Some of what the state taxes would never cross your mind.
