20 Customer Behaviors at Restaurants Americans Say Are and Aren’t Rude

Is the customer always right? If data from a recent YouGov survey is any indication, the answer is “not always.”

The way customers behave at a restaurant greatly depends on a combination of how one was raised, an individual’s personality, and cultural influences. Many of our eating-out behaviors are so ingrained in us that we don’t think about them until we witness a customer acting in a way we view as unacceptable.

Furthermore, YouGov’s data shows that what’s considered acceptable and not acceptable behavior at a restaurant can vary according to age and gender.

Measuring Misbehaving Customers

Photo Credit: hedgehog94 via stock.adobe.com.

YouGov polled 1,042 Americans in April 2024, asking them about how acceptable or unacceptable they view certain customer behaviors at restaurants. They took a random sample and weighted it according to several factors, producing an overall sample margin of error of about 4%.

The following are 20 customer behaviors at restaurants that Americans believe are the most and least acceptable.

1: Leftovers

Photo Credit: Halfpoint via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to ask for a to-go container to take home leftovers: 93%

Servers at a restaurant.

2: Sending Back Food

Photo Credit: davit85 via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to send back a dish that wasn't made as specified: 84%

3: Seat Me Now

Photo Credit: Rosemarie Mosteller via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to ask to be seated before their entire party arrives: 69%

4: Selfie Time

Photo Credit: Flamingo Images via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to take photos of their food: 75%

Tipping with a bill.

5: Split the Bill

Photo Credit: K KStock via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to ask to split the bill between a large number of people: 71%

6: Charge Up

Photo Credit: Phichat via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to ask for a table near a power outlet to charge their devices: 51%

Empty tip jar.

7: No Tip

Photo Credit: Angela Allen/Wirestock via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable not to leave a tip after receiving bad service: 51%

8: This Not That

Photo Credit: sofiko14 via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to ask for multiple modifications to a menu item: 44%

9: Taste Test First

Photo Credit: cherryandbees via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to ask to taste a bottle of wine before purchasing it: 43%

10: Let Me Think

Photo Credit: Arkady Chubykin via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to take an extended period of time to decide what to order: 48%

11: Call Me Maybe

Photo Credit: CandyBox Images via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to flirt with the staff: 23%

12: Settled In

Photo Credit: PheelingsMedia via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to occupy a table for an extended period during busy hours: 21%

13: Messes For Everyone

Photo Credit: phoderstock via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to leave a mess at the table, such as spilled drinks or food crumbs: 22%

14: Fashionably Late

Photo Credit: Nicholas F/peopleimages.com via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to show up 15 minutes late to a reservation: 17%

15: Saving Pennies

Photo Credit: Lategan/peopleimages.com via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to bring outside food or drinks into a restaurant: 14%

16: Come Here

Photo Credit: pressmaster via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to snap their fingers to get the waiter's attention: 11%

Friends eating pizza.

17: Overstaying

Photo Credit: luckybusiness via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to stay past the restaurant's closing time: 8%

18: Bartering

Photo Credit: Mariusz/peopleimages.com via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to debate menu prices with the staff: 8%

19: Free Range Kids

Photo Credit: Quality Stock Video via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to allow their children to roam freely: 5%

20: Getting Paid To Eat

Photo Credit: PR Image Factory via stock.adobe.com.

Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable to say they won't pay for a dish they didn't like but ate: 4%

The Age Divide

Photo Credit: contrastwerkstatt via stock.adobe.com.

In certain situations, YouGov’s study found a significant difference in whether people of different age groups reported customer behavior as acceptable or unacceptable. For example, 63% of people under 45 felt it’s perfectly acceptable for customers to ask for a table near an outlet, whereas only 42% of people 45+ felt the same.

In terms of how restaurants behave towards their customers, older Americans were far more likely to disapprove of communal-only seating, the exclusive use of digital menus, and loud music playing at the restaurant compared to customers under 45 years old.

Gender Differences

Friends taking a selfie.
Photo Credit: Davide Angelini via stock.adobe.com.

A Norwegian-based study revealed that females are more likely to take selfies, share selfies, and edit photos than males. It may come as little surprise, then, that more men believe taking selfies at a restaurant is unacceptable behavior compared to women.

Customer Behavior in Action

Photo Credit: Dmitry via stock.adobe.com.

Americans present themselves with many opportunities to watch customer behavior at restaurants, for as of 2022, Gen X and Baby Boomers were more likely to eat out than any other generation. Across generations, men eat out more frequently than women.

Furthermore, you may find high-income earners frequenting restaurants more often — or, at least, splurging on a few meals when they eat out. Households with $200,000+ to their names spend more than eight times as much money on eating out as households living off of less than $15,000.

24 Things You Never Knew About McDonald’s

Photo Credit: gargantiopa via stock.adobe.com.

There’s no doubt McDonald’s has left a mark on popular culture. Here are 24 facts about the burger giant that few Americans know about.  

24 Things You Never Knew About McDonald’s

From Sea to Shunned

Basket of beets.
Photo Credit: ulada via stock.adobe.com.

Taste is subjective. But when it comes to food, residents of many states appear to agree that some foods are downright gross. These are the most hated foods in each state.

From Sea to Shunned: The Most Hated Food by State

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *