Restaurants should aim to please their customers. But as many Americans unfortunately know, that’s not the case in every locale.
From blasting music so loud that diners can’t hear one another to setting strict table times, Americans feel that some restaurants fail in customer etiquette.
YouGov set out to determine which restaurant behaviors American customers believe are and aren’t acceptable. While Americans mostly understand certain behaviors that restaurants choose, the majority view others as downright cringe-worthy.
Analyzing Restaurant Etiquette
To determine the restaurant behaviors Americans think are acceptable and unacceptable, YouGov polled 1,000 participants in April 2024. They presented 40 restaurant behaviors to those surveyed and asked them to rate the acceptability of each one.
YouGov used a random sample stratified by gender, age, race, education, geographic region, and voter registration. They estimated the margin of error for their survey sample was 4%.
The following are 20 restaurant behaviors that survey participants ranked as somewhat acceptable to almost unanimously unacceptable. We ordered this list starting with the relatively most acceptable restaurant behaviors. Flip through the slideshow to see where each behavior falls.
1: No Reservations
Photo Credit: BGStock72 via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to not allow reservations: 54%
2: Cancellation Fees
Photo Credit: Africa Studio via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to charge a cancellation fee for reservations not honored: 53%
3: Formal Attire
Photo Credit: Dan Dalton/KOTO via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to require formal attire for dining: 49%
4: Perks For Reviews
Photo Credit: hakinmhan via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to offer discounts to guests who provide positive reviews online: 43%
5: Communal Seating
Photo Credit: Jacob Lund via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to offer only communal seating rather than private tables: 30%
6: No-Child Policy
Photo Credit: Mediteraneo via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to have a policy against children dining in the restaurant: 39%
7: Table Time Limits
Photo Credit: PR Image Factory via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to impose a time limit on how long guests can occupy a table: 31%
8: No-Phone Policy
Photo Credit: Cressida studio via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to have a no-phone policy at the dining table: 37%
9: Children's Menu
Photo Credit: Sanja via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to not allow grownups to order off the children's menu: 30%
10: Costly Refills
Photo Credit: Andriy Blokhin via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to charge for refills on non-alcoholic beverages: 29%
11: No Substitutions
Photo Credit: sofiko14 via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to not allow substitutions or modifications to menu items: 28%
12: Digital Menus
Photo Credit: golubovy via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to use digital menus exclusively, accessible via smartphones: 26%
13: Splitting Dishes
Photo Credit: phoderstock via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to charge to split dishes among multiple guests: 23%
14: Automatic Service Charges
Photo Credit: K KStock via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to automatically include a 20% service charge on the bill: 19%
15: Splitting the Bill
Photo Credit: Syda Productions
via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to not be willing to split the bill among multiple guests: 18%
16: Dynamic Pricing
Photo Credit: hedgehog94 via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to use dynamic pricing, in which prices vary based on demand or time: 17%
17: Playing Music
Photo Credit: Oleg Kozlovskiy via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to play music at a high volume: 12%
18: Minimum Spending
Photo Credit: Kzenon via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to require each guest to spend a minimum amount: 12%
19: No Prices
Photo Credit: wavebreak3 via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to not indicate prices next to items on the menu: 8%
20: Tap Water
Photo Credit: Syda Productions via stock.adobe.com.
Percentage of Americans who believe it's acceptable for restaurants to charge for tap water: 6%
America’s Dining Habits
Americans are no strangers to restaurants. According to a 2023 US Foods survey, the average American dines out at a restaurant three times per month. That said, delivery is a more popular option, with the same group of survey participants reporting that they order delivery an average of 4.5 times per month.
So, why do 57% of Americans prefer ordering takeout or delivery over dining in at a restaurant?
It appears poor restaurant behaviors have little to do with it. After all, many Americans have access to choose from an abundance of restaurants where they live. Instead, 76% of Americans say they prefer takeout or delivery because they enjoy eating at home. Seventy-five percent report the overall convenience of takeout and delivery attracts them to not eat at a restaurant.
Worth the Wait
Time is money. But when it comes to choosing between dining out or eating at home, it appears the majority of Americans are willing to lose both time and money.
In US Foods’ survey, 54% of customers reported being willing to wait 30 minutes or longer for their takeout or delivery order.
Income Differences
American households with $200,000+ to their name spend an average of eight times as much money on eating out than households that make under $15,000.
Of the different restaurant options available, convenience was the clear winner. Casual dining, fast food, and fast casual are Americans’ top picks for dine-in restaurant types.
24 Things You Never Knew About McDonald’s
There’s no doubt McDonald’s has left a mark on popular culture. Here are 24 facts about the burger giant that few people know about.
Stephanie Tanner’s iconic “How rude!” line from the 1987 sitcom Full House is a phrase some Americans use more than they’d like. Do you live in one of the rudest states in America?
Share on X (Twitter) Share on Facebook Share on Pinterest Share on LinkedIn Share on Flip itThe rising cost of living has many Americans looking to save money in travel and entertainment. The good news for those considering a move abroad? You can save a significant amount of money by living in certain places. U.S….
Share on X (Twitter) Share on Facebook Share on Pinterest Share on LinkedIn Share on Flip itEveryone makes grammatical mistakes, even the most well-versed English speakers. However, you’ll be hard-pressed to hear these frequent slip-ups from your English-loving friends. How many of these grammatical fails are you guilty of making? 1: You Made the Bed …
Share on X (Twitter) Share on Facebook Share on Pinterest Share on LinkedIn Share on Flip itBuying groceries in bulk may seem daunting, but this strategy can save you significant money and time. The key is to make informed choices about what to buy. Due to their longer shelf life, some food items are perfect…
Share on X (Twitter) Share on Facebook Share on Pinterest Share on LinkedIn Share on Flip itFrom the Declaration of Independence to the September 11 attacks, many events have fundamentally shaped the United States. These defining moments have had tremendous impacts on the country’s past, future, and legacy. Spanning nearly 250 years, these events represent…
Share on X (Twitter) Share on Facebook Share on Pinterest Share on LinkedIn Share on Flip itWhen you think of states with the most polite populations, which ones come to mind first? Online language learning marketplace Preply set out to discover whether stereotypes like southern hospitality and rude New Yorkers hold any truth. Preply conducted…
Share on X (Twitter) Share on Facebook Share on Pinterest Share on LinkedIn Share on Flip itWe all have habits we aren’t really proud of, and some of those affect our work days. If you find yourself struggling to be productive, check if you recognize any of these bad habits. Mindfully American compiled this list…