5 Facts Behind Virginia’s Claim That the First Thanksgiving Was at Berkeley in 1619
Thanksgiving is Nov. 26, and someone at your table is about to bring up the Pilgrims.
Virginia has an answer for that, and Texas has an answer for Virginia.
Here are the facts behind Virginia’s claim that the first Thanksgiving was at Berkeley in 1619.
1. Berkeley’s 1619 Instructions
The story begins with a document dated Sept. 4, 1619.
Four partners in the Berkeley Hundred settlement addressed it to Capt. John Woodlief, who was to govern the settlers in Virginia.
Sir William Throckmorton and George Thorpe were among the names on it.
The document tells Woodlief to keep the day the ship arrives in Virginia holy every year as a day of thanksgiving to God.
The ship, the Margaret, left Bristol, England, 12 days later.
That order is item one in Susan Myra Kingsbury’s Records of the Virginia Company of London.
Item three has everyone gather for prayer once a day, and item five calls for a strong storehouse for tools, powder, shot, armor and food.
Item six calls for at least 400 acres to be fenced in.
2. Berkeley’s Dec. 4 Date
The date in the claim is Dec. 4, 1619.
The National Park Service says settlers stepped ashore at Berkeley Hundred on the James River that day and, following the proprietor’s instruction, celebrated the first official Thanksgiving Day.
Sources differ on whether Dec. 4 was the Berkeley landing or the ship’s check-in at Jamestown.
The Pilgrims’ celebration came in the fall of 1621, nearly two years later.
3. 1931 Rediscovery
The Berkeley settlement was destroyed in 1622, a year after Plymouth’s celebration.
Its papers were in print for decades before their meaning came to light.
They were first published in 1899, Smithsonian magazine reports, but their historical significance went undetected.
That changed in 1931, when a historian stumbled on a cache of Berkeley Plantation documents.
That’s a 32-year gap.
Psst! How much do you know about Thanksgiving history? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.
Quiz
Thanksgiving History IQ
Answer these questions on Thanksgiving and early American history. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?
Sarah Josepha Hale, who also wrote the nursery rhyme about Mary’s little lamb, campaigned for a national Thanksgiving as editor of which magazine?
4. Virginia Thanksgiving Festival
Berkeley's claim has an annual commemoration, the Virginia Thanksgiving Festival.
The Washingtonian reports that descendants of Capt. Woodlief helped start it in 1958 and that it's been celebrated ever since.
It began in December.
Years ago, the date moved to November in hopes of better weather.
The 2026 festival was scheduled for Nov. 1, with an 11 a.m. parade led by the Williamsburg Pipes and Drums, a 3 p.m. re-enactment of the 1619 landing and a closing Friendship Dance led by the Chickahominy Tribal Dancers.
When the Festival Falls
Berkeley's Virginia Thanksgiving Festival is usually held on the first Sunday in November.
That puts it anywhere from Nov. 1 to Nov. 7, depending on the year.
5. Kennedy's 1963 Proclamation
President Kennedy's 1963 proclamation names Virginia, but not Berkeley, as a place where forefathers set aside a time of thanksgiving.
It puts Virginia beside Massachusetts, saying forefathers in both did so over three centuries ago.
The proclamation he signed a year earlier, on Nov. 7, 1962, mentions Plymouth and Massachusetts Bay but not Virginia.
According to Berkeley's history page, Virginia state Sen. John J. Wicker sent Kennedy a telegram on Nov. 9, 1962, taking issue with the 1962 text.
He said he had already shown the records to the governor of Massachusetts.
Presidential aide Arthur Schlesinger Jr. replied with an apology, the page says.
Governors' Proclamations
The Berkeley claim has also turned up in official state proclamations.
In 2018, then-Gov. Ralph Northam launched a yearlong commemoration of 1619 called American Evolution, Richmond Magazine reported, and the planned events included a Thanksgiving festival at Berkeley Plantation.
He listed the first representative legislative assembly in the New World and the arrival of the first recorded African people in English North America.
He also named "the first official English Thanksgiving in North America."
Then-Gov. Glenn Youngkin followed.
He issued Christian Heritage Week proclamations in 2023 and 2024.
Both describe the Dec. 4, 1619 service at Berkeley as the first Thanksgiving in the new world.
Earlier Claims Elsewhere
Texas has its own, earlier claim.
The state's Legislative Reference Library says many historians place the first U.S. Thanksgiving celebration near El Paso in 1598.
Explorers led by Don Juan de Oñate and Indigenous people celebrated with a feast and Catholic ceremonies after reaching the Rio Grande, the library says.
The Texas House and Senate each commemorated that milestone in 1990.
Historians' Caveats
The Jamestown-Yorktown Foundation's historian says Berkeley's instructions set a precedent for an annual day of thanks.
But no documentary evidence shows settlers followed the instructions.
In the foundation's account, the ship officially checked in at Jamestown on Dec. 4, then sailed about 30 miles up the James River.
It adds that the partners recruited about 35 men and chose Woodlief to command them.
Plymouth's account comes from Edward Winslow, who describes three days of feasting with Massasoit and about 90 men.
In the historian's reading, that celebration looks more like an English Harvest Home, a secular festival.
7 Virginia Fall Traditions That Can Only Happen in One Place

When the leaves turn, Virginia gives you many reasons to leave the house on a weekend.
Some of these fall traditions only happen in one spot, and even lifelong residents may not have heard of them all.
7 Virginia Fall Traditions That Can Only Happen in One Place
6 Virginia Restaurants That Closed and Are Still Missed

A Virginia newsroom asked its readers which closed restaurants they miss.
The comments filled up fast, and the answers show what a restaurant can mean to a town.
