8 Things South Carolinians Put Duke’s Mayo On That Out-of-Staters Wouldn’t

Thanksgiving is Nov. 26, and the jar of Duke’s is already out on your counter.

Not all of it ends up on bread.

Here’s what South Carolinians put Duke’s Mayo on that out-of-staters wouldn’t dream of.

1. Chocolate Cake

Duke’s chocolate cake recipe calls for 1½ cups of mayonnaise, and you won’t find eggs or oil on the ingredient list.

The frosting is a separate recipe on the same page, built on butter, cocoa, and confectioner’s sugar.

Mayonnaise in a cake?

The idea caught on during the Great Depression, when you could swap mayonnaise in for pricier eggs and oil.

Many out-of-staters would push the plate away once they hear what’s in it.

Try it anyway.

What Duke’s Leaves Out

Duke’s contains no sugar, unlike many other mass-produced mayonnaises, according to a 2018 NPR report.

Founder Eugenia Duke’s original recipe didn’t whip in egg whites as filler either.

2. Burger Patties

A Duke’s burger starts with 2 tablespoons of mayonnaise folded into the beef before you form the patties.

Duke’s goes on top too.

Many out-of-staters would stop at the beef.

3. Cracker Salad

Duke’s calls its cracker salad a Southern summer classic that’s reminiscent of a tomato sandwich.

You mix a full cup of mayonnaise with two tomatoes, half a shallot, and a sleeve of Saltine crackers.

Then you eat it fast.

For the best results, Duke’s says the salad should be eaten within minutes of being made.

Many out-of-staters would look twice if you set a salad built on crackers on the table.

4. Squash Casserole

Squash casserole is a Southern side Duke’s pairs with a holiday feast.

The recipe stirs a cup of mayonnaise into sliced squash, shredded cheddar, sour cream, and chopped onion.

Before it bakes, you top the dish with crushed crackers and melted butter.

Pass the squash.

Psst! How much do you know about South Carolina’s food and drink? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.

Quiz

Palmetto State Food IQ

Answer these questions on South Carolina food, drink and state symbols. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 9

Which drink does South Carolina’s state code name its official hospitality beverage?

5. Tomato Sandwiches

Duke's is the spread the Post and Courier's Free Times food section insists on for a tomato sandwich.

The page says few things feel like a South Carolina summer more than a tomato sandwich.

You slather Duke's on both slices of bread, then stack tomato slices between a quarter and a half inch thick.

The recipe prefers a Big Boy or Cherokee Purple tomato.

Salt and pepper go on both sides of your tomato slices.

Toasting the bread is optional.

Chips, pickled okra, or sliced cantaloupe round out the plate.

6. Pimento Cheese

If you make Duke's pimento cheese, you'll stir in 3/4 cup of mayonnaise.

Eugenia Duke first sold sandwiches to local drugstore soda fountains.

She also sold pimento cheese sandwiches to soldiers at an Army camp near Greenville during World War I, alongside egg salad and chicken salad.

They cost 10 cents each.

Duke's says its pimento cheese shows up at family gatherings and parties.

7. Deviled Eggs

Duke's classic deviled eggs recipe uses 3 tablespoons of mayonnaise for a dozen eggs.

Duke's pitches them as a must-have at bridal showers, brunches, and cookouts.

If you're making a dozen, you'll need 2 teaspoons of yellow mustard and 1½ teaspoons of dill weed too.

Duke's also posts a cacio e pepe version for cooks who want a change.

8. Potato Salad

Duke's classic potato salad uses 1 cup of mayonnaise for about 2 pounds of Yukon Gold potatoes.

Hard-boiled eggs, spicy ground mustard, dill pickles, celery, and red onion go in too.

The recipe serves six.

You chill it for at least an hour so the flavors can meld, and it can wait in your refrigerator overnight.

Where Duke's Began

Duke's began at Eugenia Duke's home on Manly Street in Greenville, where she mixed her first batch of mayonnaise.

You'll often see 1917 given as the start date, and it's the date most often cited.

Soldiers who ate her sandwiches wrote in, each asking that a jar or two be shipped to faraway Georgia or Virginia.

Demand came by mail.

In 1920, she sold the sandwich business to her bookkeeper, Alan Hart of Mauldin.

In 1923, she opened a mayonnaise plant in Greenville.

The Greenville News credits a Duke's salesman named C.B. Boyd with the idea to bottle the mayonnaise and sell it separately.

A Duke's Cookbook

The Duke's Mayonnaise Cookbook came out in June 2020 with 75 recipes from author Ashley Strickland Freeman, published by Grand Central Publishing.

Its recipes include green tomato pie, blueberry streusel muffins, and firecracker shrimp tacos.

Dessert gets its share.

If you want a triple chocolate mousse cake or banana bread made with Duke's, you'll find both in the book.

How Duke's Changed Hands

If you're wondering who owns Duke's, you'll find the answer has changed more than once since Eugenia Duke's day.

In 1929, she sold the mayonnaise business to the C.F. Sauer Company of Richmond, Virginia.

Her recipe went with it.

She moved to California, where she ran a catering business.

Sauer Brands, the parent company of Duke's, changed hands in 2025 when Boston-based private equity firm Advent International acquired it.

Falfurrias Capital Partners, a Charlotte firm, owned Sauer Brands before the sale.

The announcement left out the deal's terms.

11 Things South Carolinians Never Have to Explain to Each Other

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

South Carolinians share foods, sayings and traditions that other Americans often have to ask about.

Some things just click when you're talking to someone from the same state.

11 Things South Carolinians Never Have to Explain to Each Other

7 Things That Change the Second You Cross From North Carolina Into South Carolina

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

A state line looks like nothing on the road, but the other side may hold a few surprises.

North Carolinians and South Carolinians who make the trip may be surprised by what's different on the other side.

7 Things That Change the Second You Cross From North Carolina Into South Carolina

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *