6 Fuel Rewards Rules Ohioans Get Wrong at the Pump
Ohio’s fuel rewards programs changed hands twice in two years. Couche-Tard bought GetGo in 2025, and Kroger agreed to buy Giant Eagle for $1.65 billion this July.
The rules at the pump changed too.
You can save real money on these fuel rewards programs. But many programs are filled with rules, and not knowing them can work to your disadvantage.
These are the fuel rewards rules Ohioans get wrong at the pump.
1. Kroger Fuel Points’ Clock and Choice
Kroger Fuel Points run on a clock many shoppers never think to check.
The program’s terms erase every point on the last day of the following month, no grace period included.
A shopper who racks up points in July and plans to cash them in come September finds an empty balance.
Those July points expired at the end of August, whether anyone spent them or not.
Kroger changed the redemption rules in June 2026, letting shoppers apply up to 1,000 points toward $10 off groceries instead of gas.
Groceries and gas now compete for the same points.
A shopper who defaults every point straight to the pump never stops to check whether the grocery order would have stretched them further.
The Math Behind a Kroger Fuel Discount
Kroger’s fuel points convert at a fixed rate at the pump.
Every 100 points buys 10 cents off a gallon.
That rate caps at 1,000 points for a full dollar off.
Kroger also limits the whole discount to 35 gallons in one fill-up.
Run the numbers, and the biggest single discount a Kroger fuel center hands out comes to $35 off one trip to the pump.
2. The Kroger-Giant Eagle Deal’s Gas-Pump Gap
Kroger agreed in July 2026 to buy Giant Eagle for $1.65 billion, but the deal never touches a Giant Eagle fuel pump.
The purchase covers only Giant Eagle’s 197 supermarkets and 11 pharmacies.
GetGo, Giant Eagle’s gas station brand, isn’t part of that purchase at all.
Giant Eagle sold GetGo to Alimentation Couche-Tard, the company that owns Circle K, for $1.57 billion in June 2025, more than a year before Kroger’s agreement.
Kroger is buying groceries only.
Kroger’s announcement of the deal never mentions GetGo, Fuel Points, or myPerks.
A myPerks card still buys nothing at a Kroger fuel center, and a Kroger Fuel Point still buys nothing at a GetGo pump.
Nothing about that changes once Kroger’s purchase closes in 2027, since ownership of GetGo never passes to Kroger at all.
3. GetGo’s Grocery-Earned Perks
GetGo’s myPerks discount at the pump is earned inside a Giant Eagle or Market District store, not at the pump.
Giant Eagle’s announcement of the program spells out the rule plainly: Fuel and car wash purchases made at the pump earn no perks at all.
Gas alone buys nothing back.
A driver who fuels up at GetGo every week but skips the grocery aisles collects nothing toward that discount.
In spring 2026, GetGo ran a stretch where anyone who’d spent $100 or more at Giant Eagle or Market District got 20 cents off a gallon at GetGo.
The grocery receipt earned it, not the fill-up.
4. Circle K’s Expiring Visits
Circle K’s Inner Circle rewards run on something the chain calls a Visit, and Visits don’t bank forever.
The program’s terms cap members at five Visits a day and erase each Visit six months after it posts.
Not every Visit counts.
A Visit only counts toward a discount when a driver buys five gallons of gas or more, or spends at least $3 inside the store before tax.
A five-dollar top-off or a pack of gum doesn’t count as a Visit.
Psst! How much do you know about Ohio’s fuel and road history? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.
Quiz
Ohio Gas Station IQ
Answer these questions on Ohio’s fuel and road history. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?
Which Ohio city was home to the world’s first electric traffic signal, installed in August 1914?
5. Circle K's Giant Eagle Card Acceptance
Circle K stations across Ohio started accepting a myPerks scan at the pump this year.
Many drivers still assume that shouldn't work, since Circle K and Giant Eagle are rival chains.
Since March 24, 2026, all 285 Circle K stations in Ohio read the code inside the Giant Eagle app.
It wasn't a handshake.
Alimentation Couche-Tard, the company that bought GetGo from Giant Eagle in 2025, also owns Circle K outright.
That single parent company is why a Circle K pump can read a Giant Eagle loyalty scan in the first place.
A driver scans the code inside the Giant Eagle app at the Circle K pump, and the fuel discount earned from a grocery trip applies right there.
Circle K kept its Inner Circle program running too, so a shopper picks whichever card pays off more that week.
6. Sheetz's Two Separate Systems
Sheetz splits its fuel rewards into two separate systems that don't recognize each other's cards or points.
My Sheetz Rewardz pays five Pointz for every dollar spent inside the store, and those Pointz redeem only for a fountain drink, a coffee, or a bakery item.
None of it buys gas.
Sheetz applies a three-cent-a-gallon fuel discount automatically to anyone who's registered and opted in online, on a separate track from Pointz.
That discount shows up whether or not a driver has ever spent a single Pointz at the register.
What BP's Earnify Adds at the Pump
BP calls its rewards program Earnify in Ohio.
BP gives new members an automatic 5 cents off every gallon before they've earned a single point, according to BP's program page.
That part kicks in immediately.
Everything past that discount runs on points: A dollar spent on fuel earns one point, and a dollar spent inside a BP store earns two.
A driver decides whether those points turn into snacks or extra cents off the next fill-up.
BP layers a Visa card on top of Earnify for drivers who want a bigger discount, though the base nickel-a-gallon savings never requires the card.
Earnify answers to one company only.
GetGo changed hands in 2025, and Giant Eagle's supermarkets are set to change hands again in 2027.
Where These Discounts Don't Cross Chains
Kroger's Fuel Points and Giant Eagle's myPerks will stay separate at the pump even after the supermarket deal closes in 2027.
Kroger's purchase never touches GetGo.
Giant Eagle sold those pumps to Alimentation Couche-Tard in 2025, long before Kroger signed anything.
Sheetz and BP sit outside that entire ownership map, run independently with no ties to Kroger, Giant Eagle, GetGo, or Circle K.
A driver chasing every discount in Ohio still has to earn each program separately, one loyalty account at a time.
The choice comes down to which chain's app someone is willing to open at every single fill-up.
6 Giant Eagle Mistakes Ohio Shoppers Make Every Week
Giant Eagle retired Fuelperks+, its old pump-side loyalty program, on January 25, 2024, and rolled shoppers into myPerks instead.
The new program pays out more than the old one ever did, but a few habits at the register still cost Ohio shoppers money every week.
6 Giant Eagle Mistakes Ohio Shoppers Make Every Week
9 Ohio Car Insurance Discounts Worth Asking About Today
The average Ohio driver pays $2,259 a year for full coverage car insurance, and a chunk of that bill is avoidable.
State Farm, Nationwide, and GEICO all build discounts into their Ohio policies that many drivers never think to ask about.
