4 Food Fights That Split Michiganders, Starting With Detroit Coney vs Flint Coney

Ask two Michiganders where to get a coney dog, and be ready for an argument.

It’s not the only food the state can’t agree on.

Here are the food fights that split Michiganders, starting with Detroit Coney vs. Flint Coney.

1. Detroit Wet vs Flint Dry

A poem printed in East Village Magazine, a Flint publication, sets the wet chili of Detroit’s Greek immigrants against the dry sauce of Flint’s Macedonian immigrants.

A Detroit Coney puts a beanless chili topping on a natural-casing hot dog, usually a blend of beef and pork, in a steamed bun.

In Flint, the hot dog comes topped with a loose meat topping instead.

Flint Beat reports that the Coney came to Flint in the early 1900s, when Macedonian immigrants moved to town.

The original Flint sauce blended beef heart and kidney with beef, according to the book Two to Go.

The report describes a sauce made by boiling commercially prepared beef suet for several hours, then browning finely chopped onions in it.

A Flint company made longer buns, about seven inches long, to be a bit sturdier than a normal hot dog bun, it adds.

The first Coney restaurant in Flint, Flint Original, was downtown on Saginaw Street.

It opened in 1919 and sold as many as 4,000 Coneys a day in its prime years, 1924 to 1926.

It closed in 1979.

The Koegel’s Coney Frank

As of 2023, Koegel’s, a German meatpacking company that started in Flint in 1916, makes the Coney Frank, according to Flint Beat.

The Coney Frank has no nonfat dry milk or corn syrup.

Koegel’s sold it only to Coney restaurants in Michigan, not to grocery stores.

2. American vs Lafayette

American Coney Island and Lafayette Coney Island sit side by side in the heart of downtown Detroit.

The Christian Science Monitor calls their rivalry of more than 100 years (mostly) friendly.

Even so, a 2012 Northeast Public Radio story found that some customers will tell you they’ve never stepped into the other restaurant.

American says Gust Keros, a Greek immigrant, founded it in 1917.

According to Visit Detroit, William joined him in 1924, and Lafayette opened next door.

Visit Detroit says American is known for a slightly spicier homemade chili than Lafayette’s meatier family recipe.

It calls the choice between them a matter of preference.

William’s son George ran Lafayette until 1991, when he sold it to employees.

Joe Grimm, co-author of Coney Detroit, estimated in 2012 that Greater Detroit has about 500 Coney restaurants.

Out in Jackson, Jackson Coney Island claims to be the birthplace of the Coney dog.

A local radio profile gives its start as 1914, when George Todoroff moved his family from Macedonia.

The profile presents that as one family’s account, handed down through generations.

American’s 1917 start came three years after the 1914 date Jackson claims.

Michigan Public reports that Grimm added that stories about Jackson hosting Michigan’s first Coney island are unfounded.

Grimm also said in 2012 that no one knows for sure who brought the Coney to Detroit.

Katherine Yung says in the same Michigan Public report that the birthplace of the Coney dog has been lost to history.

The Monitor adds that Detroiters take great pride in their city’s claim to inventing the Coney dog.

That claim is disputed.

3. Jet’s vs Buddy’s

Reasonable people can disagree about whether Jet’s is Detroit style, says the host of Michigan Public’s Dough Dynasty podcast.

The podcast says Gus Guerra and those who followed his methods put the sauce on top of the cheese.

Jet’s placed its sauce between the dough and the cheese.

Karen Dybis, author of Detroit Style Pizza: A Doughtown History, says Jet’s very firmly insists it is just as Detroit style as everybody else.

Brothers Eugene and John Jetts opened Jet’s in Sterling Heights in 1978.

Dybis says Jet’s is unique in the Detroit pizza world because it patterned itself a little bit more after Little Caesars.

She says the brothers understood that what Domino’s and Little Caesars had done was replicable.

The host says it seems Jet’s was probably the first pizza chain to latch on to the style.

The podcast also says the phrase Detroit Style is new, even in Michigan, though the rectangular pizza has been around for decades.

It adds that Little Caesars began using the term Detroit Style pizza in 2022.

Gus and Anna Guerra invented the style at Buddy’s in 1946, and places like Shield’s and Loui’s eventually replicated it.

Buddy’s says its original pans came from a local auto factory, where they had held nuts and bolts.

Dybis says she can’t definitively say the pans came from an automotive plant, and that the family confirms a lot of them came from a hardware store.

She also can’t deny there’s a chance, given Gus Guerra’s automotive background.

Psst! How much do you know about Michigan food? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.

Quiz

Michigan Food IQ

Answer these questions on Michigan pastries, pasties, pizza and fudge. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 9

Pączki Day crowds are chasing a treat that began as a way to use up what before Lent?

4. Ketchup or Gravy

Metro Times says a pasty in the Upper Peninsula comes with a decision between ketchup and gravy.

Many spots offer both, it adds, though it jokes that everyone will secretly judge you for your pick.

An Upper Peninsula visitors bureau calls the question an age-old debate.

It says few questions raise as much debate in the region, and it isn't sure where the ketchup and beef gravy habits began.

The pasty itself is a Cornish tradition, and many Cornish immigrants came to the Copper Country in the mid-19th century to mine.

Finnish men ate Cornish pasties in the logging camps and the mines, Michigan Public reports.

Folklorist Yvonne Lockwood says early Cornish and Finnish immigrants likely exchanged cultures while working together in the mines.

She says her mother filled hers with pork and beef, potatoes, onions and rutabaga, plus a dab of butter before she closed it.

4 Fall Traditions Michigan and Ohio Do Completely Differently

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Michigan and Ohio both love the season.

But they don't always spend it the same way.

4 Fall Traditions Michigan and Ohio Do Completely Differently

11 Precautions Michiganders Should Take When Shopping at Meijer

Image Credit: Bruce VanLoon / Shutterstock.com.

Your mPerks points can feel like free money.

Some thieves have gone after them too.

11 Precautions Michiganders Should Take When Shopping at Meijer

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *