Alabama White Sauce Was Born at Big Bob Gibson’s in 1925. 6 Things Out-of-Staters Still Don’t Get About It

Someone from out of state sees a bowl of white sauce for the first time and says it looks like ranch.

At Big Bob Gibson’s, it started out as a dunk for their smoked chickens.

Here’s what out-of-staters still don’t get about Alabama white sauce.

1. Chicken First, Pork Later

White sauce started out as a chicken sauce, not a pork one.

The Encyclopedia of Alabama says Bob Gibson created it in Decatur in 1925.

Garden & Gun, quoting pitmaster Chris Lilly, says Gibson opened the restaurant that year.

The Southern Foodways Alliance tells it differently. In 1925, Gibson still worked for the L&N Railroad and hosted weekend barbecues in his backyard from a dugout pit.

Accounts differ.

If you’ve only ever put white sauce on pork, chicken is the older pairing.

2. Dunked, Not Drizzled

White sauce at Big Bob Gibson’s came from a dunk, not a drizzle.

Gibson split and seasoned his chickens, then roasted them over hickory wood smoke for three hours before the sauce ever touched them.

The sauce was a mayonnaise-and-vinegar mix meant to smother the smoked meat.

Mental Floss reported in 2021 that Chris Lilly says the mayonnaise keeps the chicken from drying out.

You can picture a chicken coming straight out of the smoke and into the sauce.

The Encyclopedia of Alabama adds that the sauce evolved from a kitchen staple to a table condiment.

3. Not Ranch Dressing

White sauce can pass for ranch dressing in a photo.

Many out-of-staters see the color and assume it’s the same thing.

Mental Floss says white sauce bears little flavor resemblance to the dressing.

Chris Lilly told the magazine it has a tangy, peppery flavor, so expect tang and pepper on your first taste. If you’re braced for ranch, the pepper will surprise you.

What Goes Into White Sauce

The Encyclopedia of Alabama lists white sauce as a mix of mayonnaise, apple cider vinegar, lemon juice, black pepper and salt.

4. White Sauce Isn’t All of Alabama Barbecue

White sauce is only one emblematic aspect of Alabama barbecue, according to the Encyclopedia of Alabama.

The encyclopedia’s barbecue entry places white sauce-soaked chicken on the banks of the Tennessee River.

In the north of the state, the same entry says, you’ll also find vinegar-based sauces like those in eastern North Carolina.

Eastern Alabama works mustard, a South Carolina influence, into spicy sauces, and tomato-based sauces related to those served from Memphis to eastern Tennessee turn up all over the state.

So a plate of barbecue here may not come with white sauce at all.

5. More Than a Dip

White sauce has more jobs than sitting in a bowl on the side.

In 2021, Mental Floss reported that diners put it on pork, chicken and smoked turkey, dip potato chips in it, and pour it on as a salad dressing.

If you’ve been saving white sauce for the chicken, your potato chips and salad can have some too.

6. Recipes Differ Depending on the Source

White sauce doesn’t come with one fixed recipe.

Depending on where you are in the state, versions may add sugar, horseradish or cayenne pepper.

The Encyclopedia of Alabama’s Big Bob Gibson entry describes the original base as mayonnaise, vinegar and black pepper.

The encyclopedia’s barbecue entry names apple cider vinegar and adds lemon juice and salt.

Same encyclopedia, two lists.

If you make it at home, you’re free to pick a side.

Psst! How much do you know about Southern barbecue sauce? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.

Quiz

Barbecue Sauce Showdown

Answer nine questions on Southern barbecue sauces and where they come from. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 9

In Lexington-style North Carolina barbecue, the red slaw gets its color from what?

Five Generations at the Pit

Big Bob Gibson's has stayed in the family for a century now.

In 1952, Gibson moved the restaurant to an existing building on Sixth Avenue in Decatur, the Encyclopedia of Alabama says.

He later turned the business over to his daughter, Catherine McLemore.

After Gibson died in 1972, his five grandchildren kept it going, and in 1987 they built a larger restaurant on Sixth Avenue.

A second location opened on Danville Road in 1992, the same year Chris Lilly joined the business after marrying Big Bob's great-granddaughter, Amy McLemore.

Mental Floss says five generations of the Gibson family have joined the business.

The team has won the grand championship at Memphis in May five times, in 2000, 2003, 2011, 2014 and 2017, and the restaurant marked its 100th anniversary in 2025.

If you order a plate there, you're eating from a century-old family recipe.

Beyond Decatur

White sauce has traveled well beyond Decatur, so you don't have to visit Big Bob Gibson's to taste it.

Cooks carried versions of it to other restaurants across the state.

If you've tasted white sauce somewhere besides Big Bob Gibson's, it may have been one of those versions.

Between its two locations, Big Bob Gibson's was making about 25 gallons of it a day in 2021.

The Gibson family began bottling it and selling it retail in the mid-1990s.

Southern Living readers named Big Bob Gibson Bar-B-Q White Sauce one of 50 iconic foods in July 2026, per the Encyclopedia of Alabama.

Garden & Gun put a visit to Big Bob Gibson's on its 2026 Bucket List and says its two Decatur locations now stand among Southern barbecue royalty.

By 2021, white sauce had also reached menus outside Alabama, including The Publican in Chicago and Gott's Roadside in Napa Valley.

8 Alabama Land Rules That Change the Day a Property Passes to Heirs

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Losing a family member is hard enough without land paperwork on top of it.

For Alabamians who inherit property, a few rules start working the moment ownership changes hands.

8 Alabama Land Rules That Change the Day a Property Passes to Heirs

8 Birds That Refuel on Alabama's Coast Every October Before Flying Nonstop Across the Gulf

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Tiny travelers stop along the Alabama shore each fall to eat and rest.

Ahead of them is open water with nowhere to land, so these birds are fueling up before the big trip south.

8 Birds That Refuel on Alabama's Coast Every October Before Flying Nonstop Across the Gulf

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *