Gooey Butter Cake Started as a St. Louis Baker’s Mistake, and Missourians Still Argue Over Who Made It First

You bite into a gooey butter cake and wonder who first thought of something this good.

Ask any Missourian, and you’ll hear a different story.

Here’s how gooey butter cake started as a St. Louis baker’s mistake, and who claims it first.

Coffee Cake Mix-Up

Gooey butter cake likely began as an accident by a German-American baker in south St. Louis in the 1930s, according to the Missouri Historical Society, as reported by Fox 2.

Legend has it that the baker reversed the proportions of butter and flour in a coffee cake.

Another telling says the baker added too much butter to the batter.

A 2008 St. Louis Public Radio report called the 1930s story folklore, with a baker mixing up the flour and sugar proportions for coffee cake.

The baker sold the batch anyway during hard economic times, and other bakers around St. Louis reportedly picked up on the cake once it sold well.

The original bakery versions generally used a yeast dough base, according to Illinois Times.

That’s the legend.

If you’ve had a square, you’ve eaten what the legend calls a mistake.

If you ask which bakery started it, three names come up: Koppe Bakery, Danzer’s and St. Louis Pastries.

Danzer’s Version

If you want a name and a date for the mistake, Richard Danzer’s version of gooey butter cake has both.

Danzer’s father, Herman, ran Danzer’s Bakery, and Richard submitted the family story to the food-history site What’s Cooking America in 2006.

In his telling, Johnny Hoffman of St. Louis Pastries made the cake by mistake in late 1942 or early 1943.

Danzer says the information he has comes from his mother, Melba.

Hoffman then called Herman Danzer, and the two worked all Saturday, through many trials and errors, until the cake was pretty good.

Richard Danzer says his father suggested adding glycerin to get the cake gooier.

Melba supposedly tasted the cake and remarked on how gooey it was.

If you take his account at face value, the name came from that remark.

The name stuck.

Koppe’s Version

Did Johnny Hoffman start gooey butter cake?

Marilyn Koppe Galati credits her father, John Koppe, with developing the cake in the early 1940s.

Galati says that as far as she knows, her father created the cake.

If you’re weighing the two stories, the timelines overlap.

Koppe Bakery was on the corner of California and Arsenal streets in south St. Louis.

Galati places his work during World War II and calls the cake a major hit.

She doesn’t know how he came up with the recipe, only that it could have been an accident.

After the war, her account goes, Koppe sold his business and went to work for St. Louis Pastries.

If you’re keeping score, that’s the same bakery where Hoffman made his mistake in Danzer’s version.

The stories collide.

Psst! How much do you know about Missouri’s food and drinks? Take our quiz and see if you can ace it.

Quiz

Missouri Food IQ

Answer these questions on St. Louis and Missouri food and drinks. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 8

Missouri law names an official state dessert. Which one is it?

Other Theories

Sugar rationing during World War II gives gooey butter cake a wartime explanation, according to Missouri Life.

One version holds that three bakers ran short of rations and used powdered sugar instead of granulated sugar.

If you're looking for a St. Charles connection, that version is tied to Little O's Old Time Soda Fountain.

Another credits recipes shared at union bakers' meetings.

Even the decade is disputed.

Pick the 1930s or the 1940s, and you'll find an account to match.

One account puts the mistake in the 1940s, with a baker using too much glycerin and not enough leavening.

The Historical Society points to the 1930s instead.

Missing Records

Few doubt that St. Louis gave birth to gooey butter cake, Illinois Times noted in 2010.

The dispute centers on which baker gets the credit.

The Danzer and Koppe accounts both come from family members recalling relatives.

Richard Danzer allows that the true story may stay a matter of guesswork.

He adds that his mother, then approaching 89, has none of Herman's recipes and no way of proving the story.

Marilyn Koppe Galati says she knows of no proof of who created the recipe.

Both of her parents have died, she says, and no records about the dessert were kept.

If you're hoping for a tiebreaker, St. Louis Magazine's dining editor told Vox magazine in 2024 that nothing about the origin has been verified or confirmed.

If you check Fodor's, you'll find the same point.

The cake's origin has never been historically verified, despite many strong claims and opinions.

It's a stalemate.

Who Claims the Original

If you want to try gooey butter cake near Affton, Federhofer's Bakery, on Gravois Road, is in a 2026 St. Louis Magazine roundup.

Fodor's says Federhofer's claims to use the original recipe.

St. Louis Magazine says Straub's Fine Grocers sticks close to the original recipe.

Which one is original?

If you're asking, none of these claims settles it.

Park Avenue Coffee started selling gooey butter cake at its original cafe in Lafayette Square.

Missouri Life reported in 2017 that the company tells the Hoffman and Danzer account, including Johnny Hoffman's mistake and his call to Herman Danzer.

Gooey Louie specializes in gooey butter cake.

Explore St. Louis recommends Gooey Louie's individual cakes as gifts for holiday hosts.

10 Things You Only Understand About Missouri After a Few Years There

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Somewhere around your second or third year in Missouri, something shifts.

You stop asking why things work the way they do, and you start explaining them to the next newcomer.

10 Things You Only Understand About Missouri After a Few Years There

5 Checkout Traps That Can Cost Missourians More Than They Save

Image Credit: JHVEPhoto / Shutterstock.com.

You walk out of the store with a receipt that says you saved money.

It may not say how much you spent to get there.

5 Schnucks Checkout Traps That Can Cost Missourians More Than They Save

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *