Hannaford Rates Its Food With Guiding Stars. 6 Things Granite Staters Miss About the Stars on the Shelf Tags

You pick the organic option at Hannaford, and the shelf tag next to it has no stars.

The stars probably aren’t grading what you think they are.

Here’s what Granite Staters miss about the stars on Hannaford’s shelf tags.

Note: This is general information, not medical or nutrition advice. Guiding Stars ratings and the products on Hannaford’s shelves are subject to change, so talk to a doctor or registered dietitian about your diet.

1. Ratings by Department

Guiding Stars, the program behind the stars on Hannaford’s shelf tags, has published how often each kind of food earns them.

Across the U.S. food products the program has analyzed, about 27% earn one or more stars.

Fresh fruits and vegetables reach 100%, and seafood and seafood alternatives come in at 61%.

Breakfast cereals come in at 45%, while meat and meat alternatives sit at 27% and dairy and dairy alternatives at 16%.

Those shares cover products analyzed nationwide, so if you shop Hannaford, the mix on your shelves can differ.

2. Tags With No Stars

If you spot a Hannaford shelf tag with no stars, it doesn’t always mean the food fell short.

Many shoppers read a missing star as a bad grade.

The Guiding Stars FAQ lists three reasons a product can go without stars.

The food might not meet the nutritional criteria.

It might have five or fewer calories per serving, like spices.

Or it might be a baby formula, alcohol, variety pack, dietary supplement or medical food.

You’ll see a rating only when an item earns one, two or three stars, so products that miss aren’t shamed.

3. What Isn’t in the Formula

Several things you might weigh at the Hannaford shelf never enter a Guiding Stars rating.

Organic, natural and GMO claims aren’t in the formula, and the program says science doesn’t currently show a meaningful nutritional benefit or drawback for them.

A bag of organic quinoa, for example, gets no bonus for the word organic.

The formula leaves out protein, and it debits saturated and trans fat but not total fat.

If you’re comparing a regular version of a food with a low-fat one, the regular version can earn more stars.

Makers may add sugar or salt to a low-fat version for taste.

How Hannaford’s Stars Are Scored

Under the Guiding Stars rating methodology, which sets the stars on Hannaford’s shelf tags, foods are scored on a 100-calorie serving and drinks on a 12-ounce serving.

In the general foods formula, fiber, vitamins and minerals, omega-3s, whole grains and live active cultures earn points.

Added sodium, added sugar, saturated fat, trans fat and what the program calls additives to limit take points away.

A positive total earns one, two or three stars.

A negative total earns none.

4. Comparing Within One Category

Guiding Stars on a Hannaford shelf tag are meant to help you pick the more nutritious option within a category, such as two kinds of cereal.

The program says they aren’t designed for comparing foods across categories, such as a serving of grapes with a serving of yogurt.

Guiding Stars runs five algorithms, including separate ones for beverages and for meats, poultry, seafood, dairy and nuts.

If you’re comparing two brands of yogurt, that’s where you can lean on the stars.

5. Store Brands and Name Brands

Hannaford’s store brands and the name brands beside them get the same criteria from Guiding Stars.

The program says price, brand and manufacturer don’t influence the stars you see.

Hannaford’s Snack Pals site said in May 2024 that the icons appear on store-brand packaging as well as shelf tags.

When you compare a Hannaford-brand box with a name-brand one, the stars come from the same formula.

6. Label Data Behind the Stars

For packaged foods, the stars on a Hannaford tag come from the Nutrition Facts label and ingredient list.

For foods with no label, such as meats, fruits, seafood and vegetables, the program uses data from the U.S. Department of Agriculture’s National Nutrient Database.

A maker can list just the mandatory vitamins and minerals, which are vitamin D, calcium, iron and potassium.

The program says products with less label information may receive a lower rating.

When you compare two similar products, the one that prints less on its label may rate lower.

When your usual brand revises a formula or its packaging, Guiding Stars reviews and reevaluates the updated information each time.

Where the Stars Began

Guiding Stars started at Hannaford in September 2006.

A scientific advisory panel co-led by a nutrition expert at Dartmouth Medical School in Hanover, New Hampshire, established the system.

By then, the program had analyzed more than 27,000 items in Hannaford stores across the Northeast.

At launch, the system didn’t consider how much a product cost or whether it was a store brand.

Guiding Stars refreshed its look in 2021 with a new apple icon and the words good, better or best.

The outlined stars on one- and two-star graphics show the rating is out of a possible three.

Guiding Stars says its ratings are on shelf tags at all Hannaford stores.

Hannaford’s store directory lists stores in 31 New Hampshire towns, so you can look for the tags in any of them.

Psst! How much do you know about the labels on your groceries? Take our quiz and see how many you can get right.

Quiz

Label Know-How

Answer these questions on food labels and New Hampshire groceries. We bet you can’t get them all right. Prove us wrong?

Question 1 of 9

New Hampshire’s official state fruit is which of these?

Checking Ratings Online

The store page for Hannaford's New London location says you can filter your search by store brands, food allergies and Guiding Star ratings.

If you have a question about a rating, the FAQ encourages you to talk with an in-store dietitian.

Guiding Stars also runs a Food Finder, a database of thousands of foods that shows their star ratings.

You can search it by product name or brand, or browse by food category.

8 Highway Habits That Instantly Tell a Massachusetts Driver From a New Hampshire One

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Could you tell a Massachusetts driver from a New Hampshire driver in under a minute?

A handful of habits on the road can give it away.

8 Highway Habits That Instantly Tell a Massachusetts Driver From a New Hampshire One

6 Things New Hampshire Towns Do Every Foliage Season

Image Credit: Shutterstock.com.

Your leaves may be glowing orange while the next town over is still green.

New Hampshire towns plan their foliage season around that.

6 Things New Hampshire Towns Do Every Foliage Season

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *